13,074 Monticello IN Homes Between 400k and 800k

 Refine Search
Sort by
2710 E State Road 32, Crawfordsville
$1,250,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
The possibilities are endless, nestled within the serene rural area of 2710 E State Road 32, Crawfordsville, IN, this historic residence in Montgomery County presents an attractive property in great condition, poised to become your personal haven. The main house dates back to 1872, and offers a unique blend of historical charm such as hardwood floors, gorgeous wood work, but with all the modern updates. The heart of this home resides in its kitchen, a space designed for both culinary artistry and social gatherings. With five bedrooms and five full bathrooms spread across two stories, this expansive 4981 square foot home provides ample space for comfortable living. You will also find a separate mother in law type addition, complete with a kitchen, bathroom and family room, could also be used as a home office. Additionally, the property features a beautiful, well crafted 1 bedroom, 1 full bathroom, yurt. Perfect for your own personal get-away, for family, or for producing income. Both the main house and yurt are featured on airbnb and are heavily booked. Sitting on 28 acres with a mix of woods, trails, and open ground, this captivating property offers a unique opportunity to own a substantial piece of history, perfectly suited for creating lasting memories. Truly a must see! Easy access to I74. North Montgomery Schools

2710 E State Road 32, Crawfordsville

Listing courtesy of Sarah DeVore. Keller Williams-Morrison

19720 Chatsworth Boulevard, Westfield
$1,249,946
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
*Photos are of similar plan or virtually staged, actual home features may vary. A David Weekley Home that grows with you across three full levels, the Whitmore offers rare depth for families who need both space to gather and space to breathe. The main floor anchors daily life around an open kitchen, family room, and dining area, while the Owner's Retreat - complete with sitting room and walk-in closet - provides a private sanctuary without leaving the first floor. Upstairs, a second-floor retreat connects three generously sized bedrooms and provides a flexible space for work, study, or play. The finished basement adds a sixth bedroom, game room, and full bath - ideal as a guest suite, recreation hub, or multi-generational living space. A dedicated study and covered porch round out a plan that balances openness and intention at every turn. As a resident of Chatham Village, you'll also enjoy access to the exceptional amenities of Chatham Hills, including a clubhouse, golf course, swimming pools, walking trails, and more.*Price reflects Builder Incentive.

19720 Chatsworth Boulevard, Westfield

Listing courtesy of Angela Huser. Weekley Homes Realty Company

20821 Anthony Road, Noblesville
$1,225,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
RARE 7.1-ACRE OPPORTUNITY ON HIGHLY DESIRABLE ANTHONY ROAD IN WESTFIELD! This exceptional property combines luxury living, privacy and versatility in a setting that is increasingly difficult to find in Westfield. Located within Westfield-Washington Schools and outside a traditional subdivision, this beautifully reimagined brick ranch is paired with an impressive Morton pole barn and established amenities for horses, livestock, hobbies and more. The home has been extensively renovated with high-end finishes and thoughtful details throughout. At the heart of the home is a stunning gourmet kitchen featuring custom cabinetry, quartz countertops and an open, inviting design perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The spacious primary suite is a true retreat, complete with a spa-inspired bath, oversized custom walk-in closet and conveniently located laundry. A flexible office provides additional usable space and offers the potential for conversion to a third bedroom to accommodate a buyer's needs. Outside is where this property truly sets itself apart. The expansive Morton pole barn offers incredible versatility, including a large insulated and heated area, two large horse stalls, two additional pens and a feed area. Whether you're an equestrian, 4-H or livestock family, car enthusiast, hobby farmer, collector, or simply need exceptional workshop and storage space, this property is ready to accommodate your lifestyle. The 7.1 acres provide space to enjoy the outdoors, animals and country living while remaining close to everything Westfield has to offer. Established fencing and animal infrastructure make this an opportunity that would be difficult-and costly-to recreate. This is more than a beautifully renovated home-it's a rare opportunity to enjoy the freedom and versatility of country living without giving up the conveniences of Westfield.

20821 Anthony Road, Noblesville

Listing courtesy of Jennifer Kimball. Grange Real Estate

468 Village Green Drive, Carmel
$1,216,187
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Elevate your lifestyle with the stunning 3 Story Townhome in JG Village of Carmel, an exceptional residence brought to you by the McKenzie Collection. Designed for those who value both luxury and thoughtful functionality, this townhome redefines sophisticated urban living across three impeccably designed levels. Step inside to over 3,100 square feet of exquisitely finished living space where elegance meets innovation. The main living room showcases two striking ceiling beams, adding architectural depth to the open-concept design. Just off the main living area, a dedicated office space offers privacy with sleek pocket doors -perfect for remote work or quiet retreat. The heart of the home, the kitchen, exemplifies modern luxury with custom stacked cabinetry, a quartz waterfall island, and premium Sub-Zero Wolf appliances. Take the elevator, or earn your steps up the hardwood stairs that enhance the home's timeless design, while 10' ceilings on the main floor and 9' ceilings on the upper levels amplify the sense of spaciousness. Smart and sustainable features abound, including a video doorbell, Brilliant smart home technology, an EV charger in the garage, and energy-efficient spray foam insulation for added soundproofing and comfort. The third floor is where luxury outdoor living takes center stage. A direct vent gas linear fireplace anchors the expansive outdoor rooftop area. Entertain with ease at the 8' wet bar with under-cabinet refrigerator, cook out using the gas line ready for a grill, or prepare for future relaxation with a hot tub rough-in. Unlike typical plans, this layout includes a full bath with a shower, maximizing functionality for guests and residents alike. From its elevated finishes to its cutting-edge smart tech and rooftop retreat, every detail embodies intentional design and refined living-making this more than just a home, but a true sanctuary. Anticipated completion is December 2026.

468 Village Green Drive, Carmel

Listing courtesy of Erin Hundley. Compass Indiana, LLC

11773 W County Road 275 Road N, West Baden Springs
$1,200,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
LOST RIVER RIDGE WHERE DREAMS BECOME A DESTINATION @ THE END OF YOUR DAY * THIS MEMORY MAKER LOG HOME IS BEAUTIFULLY SITUATED ON 40+ AC SURROUNDED BY HOOSIER NATIONAL FOREST * CUSTOM ARCHED GATE WELCOMES YOU & THE WINDING DRIVE LEADS YOU TO A LIFESTYLE YOU HAVE BEEN DREAMING OF * CURRENTLY A WELL ESTABLISHED 5-YEAR TURNKEY STR * YEAR ROUND LIVING OR BUSINESS OPPORTUNITY * EXPERIENCE EVERYDAY NATURE & STUNNING PANORAMIC VIEWS OF THE LOST RIVER & VALLEY * STEP INSIDE AND EMBRACE THE WARMTH & AMBIENCE OF THIS STUNNING HOME FEATURING HANDCRAFTED DETAIL, FLOWING SPACE & MODERN CONVENIENCES * HIGH END FINISHES INCLUDE AVONITE SOLID SURFACE, CAMBRIA QUARTZ, INT/EXT CUSTOM IRONWORK * 3-LEVELS * 5,340 S.F. * 6 BED * 4 BA * WALK-OUT BASEMENT * EXPANSIVE COVERED WRAP AROUND PORCHES * 33 X 23 G/R FEATURES FIELDSTONE F/P * MAIN LVL OWNER'S ENSUITE * FORMAL D/R * KITCHEN W/S-S APPLIANCES SEP BREAKFAST ROOM W/SPIRAL STAIRCASE TO LOFT/OFFICE (CURRENTLY BED 7) * UPPER LEVEL OFF G/R LOFT/LIBRARY + BED * FINISHED LL OFFERS 4 BED, FAMILY ROOM, 2 BATHS, UTILITY - DID YOU FIND THE SECRET PASSAGE? * SEVERAL OUTBUILDINGS * 40 x 60 RUSTIC PARTY BARN (3-STORY) W/2-BLT IN BARS * RV STORAGE W/2-50 AMP RV HOOKUPS * NEWER 40 x 80 POLE BARN PLUMBED & INT FRAMED FOR FINISH * SEPARATE COTTAGE CABIN PERFECT FOR CARETAKER RESIDENCE * EXPAND YOUR OUTDOOR LIFESTYLE WITH ENDLESS OPPORTUNITIES TO HUNT-HIKE-FISH EXPLORE * POND SITE EVAL FOR WATER HOLDING POTENTIAL * UNIQUE & CUSTOM IRON LOOKOUT TOWER * THIS LIFESTYLE IS ONLY A SHORT DRIVE TO THE AMENITIES OF WEST BADEN, FRENCH LICK & PATOKA LAKE * WFH WITH EASE USING THE HIGH SPEED OC REMC GIGABIT INTERNET & COMMERCIAL GRADE INDOOR OUTDOOR WI-FI * ONE LOOK AND YOU WILL WANT TO CALL THIS HOME!

11773 W County Road 275 Road N, West Baden Springs

Listing courtesy of Arla Frazier. Ever Real Estate, LLC

100 W South, Greenfield
$1,200,000
Use S 125 W, Greenfield for GPS mapping. A rare opportunity to acquire 39.7 acres in Hancock County, offering a compelling combination of open ground, natural beauty, and long-term potential. Located at 100 W South, this agricultural property offers a blank canvas with no existing buildings and the flexibility to explore a variety of possibilities, subject to applicable zoning, approvals, and due diligence. The property's natural setting adds to its appeal, with Wilson's Ditch winding through mature trees to create a wooded backdrop and a distinctive sense of character. The combination of open acreage and wooded areas provides both scale and variety, making this an exceptional opportunity for those seeking land with room to envision what comes next. Situated near Greenfield and within the New Palestine school district, the property offers a location connected to two communities that continue to attract interest throughout Hancock County. Opportunities to acquire nearly 40 acres in this setting are increasingly difficult to find. For those seeking additional acreage, 100 W South is also available as part of a separate offering combining three connected parcels totaling 82.41 acres for $2.2M, including 125 W South and 350 W South (listed under 125 W South). Drive the property, take in the setting, and imagine what 39.7 acres of connected land could become.

100 W South, Greenfield

Listing courtesy of Samuel Hawkins. F.C. Tucker Company

704 N Highland, Indianapolis
$1,200,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Cottage Home sits at the center of everything Indianapolis has become - steps from Mass Ave, Bottleworks, and the Factory Arts District, with both the Cultural Trail and the Monon Trail at your doorstep. Coffee shops, restaurants, a movie theater, boutique shopping - all walkable. And right here on this block, a neighborhood park and community gathering space that makes it feel less like a city street and more like a place you actually belong. Built in 2023 and finished with the kind of intentionality you feel the moment you walk through the door, this 4-bedroom, 4.5-bath residence offers a rare combination of luxury, flexibility, and location. Hardwood floors carry through the entire first and second floor. A gas fireplace anchors the living space. The chef's kitchen is outfitted with a paneled refrigerator, walk-in pantry, and everything a serious cook could ask for - and the mudroom means the rest of the house stays exactly as polished as it looks. A large front porch welcomes you home, and a covered back porch with ceiling fan gives you an outdoor living space you'll actually use. Every bedroom has its own en-suite bath and walk-in closet - no compromises, no sharing. And with primary suite options on both the main floor and the second floor, this home adapts to however your life is arranged. The full finished basement adds even more living space, and the three-car garage means parking is never a second thought. Then there's the carriage house - a fully self-contained one-bedroom, one-bath retreat above the garage. Guest quarters, rental income, a private studio - the possibilities are yours to decide. This is downtown Indianapolis living at its absolute finest.

704 N Highland, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Jess Martin. Maywright Property Co.

9651 W Shore Drive, Columbus
$1,200,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to a truly special lakefront retreat at Harrison Lake w/Harrison Lake Country Club less than 1 mile away! Situated on a desirable point with beautiful panoramic views, this meticulously maintained home blends original character with thoughtful modern updates. With its distinctive board-and-batten-over-concrete architecture and clean lines, that is both timeless and inviting. Step inside through the brick-floored foyer and into a spacious living room featuring a gas fireplace, built-in bookshelves and expansive views of the patio and lake beyond. An adjoining office area tucked behind the fireplace provides a quiet and convenient workspace. The main-level primary suite is generously sized and offers direct access to a covered porch. The updated primary bath in the hallway delivers a modern, upscale feel with contemporary tile, a walk-in shower, double sinks and stylish mirror features. Two additional bedrooms are served by an updated Jack-and-Jill bath. The kitchen is truly the heart of the home, featuring hardwood floors, stainless steel appliances, abundant cabinetry, generous counter space and a large dining area perfect for gatherings. From the kitchen, newer Pella four-panel sliding doors open to a spacious porch overlooking the lake. Designed for year-round enjoyment, the porch features a fireplace, high-tech, all-weather window coverings that create a comfortable three-season living space while still allowing you to enjoy the fresh air. The walk-out lower level expands the home's entertaining possibilities with a wood-burning fireplace, comfortable gathering area, wet bar with refrigerator, additional recreation space and abundant storage. In less than 25 ft walk out to the sunning deck and enjoy the peaceful setting and beautiful water views. For the boating enthusiast, the private dock accommodates two boats and includes 1 boat lift. This is more than a lakefront home- it is a Turnkey opportunity from Day 1. A truly rare offering with water access.

9651 W Shore Drive, Columbus

Listing courtesy of Molly Lawless. F.C. Tucker Company

2600 Troy Avenue, New Castle
$1,200,000
Exceptional opportunity to acquire a 78,000 square-foot industrial/ manufacturing facility located in the Henry County Industrial Park in New Castle. Situated on 20+ acres, this well-maintained property offers ample room for current operations and future expansion. The facility features approximately 2,000 square feet of office space, providing an efficient administrative area while maximizing manufacturing and warehouse operations. With 16-foot clear ceiling heights and four convenient loading docks, the building is well-suited for manufacturing, warehousing, distribution, fabrication, or other industrial uses. The expansive site provides abundant parking, outdoor storage potential, and significant acreage for future growth or additional development. Located in a well-established industrial park, the property benefits from excellent access for commercial transportation and logistics. New Castle is known for its dependable, skilled workforce and business-friendly environment, making this an ideal location for companies seeking to expand or relocate their operations.

2600 Troy Avenue, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Michael McKown. F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

6230 E 56th, Indianapolis
$1,200,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Welcome to the historic Brendonwood, Indianapolis' premier estate community, this exceptional residence offers a rare blend of timeless architecture, resort-inspired amenities & modern luxury. Surrounded by mature trees & rolling landscape, guests are welcomed by a dramatic 2-story limestone portico, manicured grounds, custom lighting, a tranquil koi pond & an expansive driveway complete w/a 3car garage & basketball court creating an unforgettable arrival experience. At the heart of the home is a showstopping chef's kitchen featuring an oversized quartz waterfall island w/seating for 5-6, full-height quartz backsplash, brushed gold fixtures, farmhouse prep sink, pot filler, 48" ZLINE dual oven gas range w/griddle, FORNO hood, beverage fridge, ice maker, coffee station, illuminated wine display niches, floor-to-ceiling cabinetry, glass display cabinets, serving buffet & designer lighting. Coffered ceilings, extensive trim details & wide plank tile flooring seamlessly connect the kitchen, breakfast room & great room, creating an ideal setting for entertaining. The thoughtfully designed floorplan offers spacious gathering areas, a private fitness center, dedicated theater room, expansive lower-level entertaining spaces & beautifully appointed bedrooms for family & guests. The primary retreat serves as a true sanctuary featuring a generous sleeping area, spa-inspired bath & custom walk-in closet. Living in Brendonwood means enjoying one of Indianapolis' most treasured lifestyles with access to a private 9-hole golf course, historic Common House, wooded walking opportunities, Fall Creek views & a true sense of community, all just minutes from downtown, premier healthcare, dining, shopping & cultural attractions. Opportunities to own within Brendonwood are rare. This is more than a home it is an invitation to experience one of Indianapolis' most extraordinary communities.

6230 E 56th, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Denae Lewis. Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

8160 State Road 135  S, Freetown
$1,200,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Here it is -A RARE opportunity to own a Private, Custom Built, D-Log Cabin with PROW (ship-like) architectural design nestled on 56+ acres with a 2350SF pole barn that includes more living space and RV storage! This cabin boasts multiple screened-in, wrap around porches on the lower & upper levels for add'l indoor/outdoor living space! Soaring 25 foot ceilings, custom built Amish cabinetry in kitchen & throughout, hickory wood flooring, & a grand fireplace greet you upon entering. Enjoy a custom kitchen w/ large granite top island, 3 bdrms w/high ceilings, custom California closets, real wood doors, & screened in sleeping porches off of the upstairs bedroom. A temperature controlled wine cellar, a dog bath, & large laundry room are bonuses of this home. Other features include an add'l bdrm & bath in the pool barn that is great for shop/equipment/RV storage, entertainment space, you name it! A chicken coop, a creek, raised garden beds, a large fenced in area, firepit, a freshly asphalted driveway for easy access, updated septic system, are just a few more of the add'l amenities this beautiful cabin has to offer! Make this private oasis with breathtaking hilltop views yours today!

8160 State Road 135 S, Freetown

Listing courtesy of Rachel Freitas. Berkshire Hathaway Home

138 Ulen Boulevard, Lebanon
$1,200,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Welcome to one of the most exceptional homes in the historic and highly sought-after Ulen community. Perfectly positioned on the 3rd tee box of the prestigious Ulen Golf Course, this remarkable residence offers nearly 6,000 sf of beautifully updated living space, combining timeless elegance, modern luxury, and breathtaking golf course views. This stately brick home features 6 bdrm, 4.5 bathrooms, and an ideal floor plan designed for both everyday living and grand-scale entertaining. Upon entering, you'll be greeted by sophisticated finishes, extensive millwork, rich hardwood floors, and spacious gathering areas filled with natural light. The heart of the home is the stunning gourmet kitchen, showcasing custom cabinetry, marble countertops, high-end appliances, a large center island, built-in seating, and picturesque views of the surrounding landscape. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the dining and family living spaces, creating the perfect setting for entertaining family and friends. The luxurious main-level primary suite serves as a private retreat, featuring expansive windows overlooking the golf course, direct access to the covered patio, a huge walk-in closet, and a beautifully renovated spa-inspired bathroom complete with custom cabinetry, dual vanities, and an oversized walk-in marble shower. Additional living spaces include a formal living room, elegant dining room, private office/library, and an impressive 30' x 30' bonus room offering endless possibilities for a recreation room, media room, fitness studio, playroom, or additional entertaining space.Outdoor living is equally impressive with mature trees, professionally maintained landscaping, a covered patio, and stunning views of the historic Ulen Golf Course. Enjoy peaceful mornings, spectacular sunsets, and the unique lifestyle that comes with living in one of Central Indiana's most treasured golf communities. Opportunities to own a home of this caliber, size, and location in Ulen are exceedingly rare.

138 Ulen Boulevard, Lebanon

Listing courtesy of Ryan Richardson. Richardson Realty Company, LLC

850 W County Road 1000  N, Roachdale
$1,200,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Professional Equine Training/Boarding Facility on 47.51 acres. The main barn is 134' x 250' totaling 33,500 square feet! This barn is a Steel Framed barn with concrete foundation that is heated with a wood burning boiler. The main barn contains a 100'x200' indoor arena, 26 horse stalls, 2 garage/shop areas, plus 3 separate apartments. Also included is a remodeled 70'x15' house trailer plus a 72'x108' pole barn for equipment and hay storage. This property has several fenced pastures & out lots with automatic waterers and tillable land for hay or row crops. Several premium building sites exist to build your home, your way! You have to come see all of the extra features this property has to appreciate it! This facility is ready to start your horse operation today!

850 W County Road 1000 N, Roachdale

Listing courtesy of Brandon Lawson. Weichert, Realtors - Lawson & Co.

8151 E Southport Road, Indianapolis
$1,200,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Location, location, location. 3.73 Acres. Looking for a fast growing area with many new business' being developed around the site in Franklin Township. The property is in the comprehensive plans for the township to be Commercial office use. This can include office building, Doctor/dental office, daycare, extended care facilities, funeral home, and many other options. The home itself could be converted into an office. Great home, completely remodeled in 2013, including two HVAC units, salt water pool pump 2022, pool cover 2024. Larger garage is completely finished inside with insulation and separate fuel tank for heating. Many new subdivisions are in various locations around this home site. Kroger with strip mall and McDonald's, Starbucks, Dunkin, Dental Office, Day Care Center, directly across the street and Franciscan office space next door. Lease option would be considered.

8151 E Southport Road, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Cheri Meeks. Hoosier, REALTORS®

Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative as distributed by MLS GRID.


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!