Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$47,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
This is a 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home with a 1-car garage. It is conveniently located near parks, an aquatic center, and ball fields. Please note that this property is a fixer-upper that needs TLC and is being sold "as is"

1222 Webster Avenue, New Castle

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC.

$239,900
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
This 19th-century farmhouse truly commands attention as you approach, standing alone against the landscape. The main level includes two living areas, an eat-in kitchen plus dining room, one bedroom and a full bath, while the second floor provides three more bedrooms. Outdoors, choose to relax on the covered, wrap around porch or enjoy your favorite beverage on the large, uncovered deck. A must see property in rural Henry County.

5131 E County Road 300 S, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$99,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Updated 2-bedroom home with immediate possession available! This property features numerous recent improvements including newer roof shingles, vinyl siding, vinyl replacement windows, and updated kitchen cabinets with granite countertops. Interior highlights include vinyl plank flooring throughout the main living areas and carpeted bedrooms for added comfort. The living room offers an electric fireplace, creating a warm and inviting space. The eat-in kitchen provides ample cabinet space and functionality, along with a convenient main-level laundry room. The bathroom has been tastefully updated with a claw foot tub, subway tile, and shiplap accents, blending modern updates with classic charm. Additional features include a partial basement with a 90+ high-efficiency gas furnace and central air, a one-car detached garage with built-in storage, and a partially fenced backyard. A great opportunity for owner-occupants or investors alike!

2029 Lincoln Avenue, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Taflinger Real Estate Group.

$675,000
Historic presence, bold scale, and the kind of opportunity that rarely comes along, this standout New Castle property delivers it all. Built in 1847 by Mason Livezey for the Eli Murphy family, this two-story structure offers over 4,100 square feet and sits on a hard to find 0.75 acre lot right in the heart of town. From the moment you arrive, the architectural character makes an impression-timeless, substantial, and ready for its next chapter. The heavy lifting has already been done, giving you a strong head start. All five chimneys have been completely rebuilt, a new roof with slate look shingles adds both durability and style, and fresh interior and exterior paint create a clean, refreshed feel throughout. New flooring has been installed, along with new shutters and soffit, while the columns have been reworked to ensure long-term structural integrity, preserving the look while strengthening the foundation for what comes next. And then there's the feature that truly sets this property apart, its dedicated parking lot. In a downtown setting where parking is often limited, this is a rare and valuable asset that adds everyday convenience and long-term appeal. With its size, history, and extensive updates already in place, this property offers the kind of flexibility and presence that invites creativity. Whether you're envisioning a residential restoration, a business venture, or a blend of both, this is a space with stories behind it, and plenty more waiting to be written.

321 S Main Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$675,000
Step into a true transformation opportunity at 1214 Broad Street, planted right in the center of downtown New Castle, where every great revitalization story begins. This former Town Tavern space delivers instant character with its original bar anchoring the main level, creating a natural focal point for a reimagined hospitality concept, retail experience, or hybrid venue. Behind the scenes, the heavy lifting has already started with a new roof, new first-floor HVAC system, and updated storefront windows and exterior doors, giving you a strong foundation to build on. What truly sets this property apart is its attached parking lot - an uncommon advantage in this downtown corridor that adds both function and long-term value. Upstairs, the second and third floors offer unfinished space ready for a complete design vision - think loft-style residences, studio spaces, or income-producing units layered above your main-level concept. This is more than a property, it's a canvas with structure, story, and location already in place. For those with an eye for design and a plan for execution, 1214 Broad Street is ready to be taken from raw potential to a standout destination.

1214 Broad Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$15,999
Wooded Tract with Convenient City Access Nestled on a 0.55-acre tract, this heavily wooded property offers a serene and private retreat while being conveniently located. With frontage along Garner Street, the land benefits from easy access to city utilities, ensuring modern conveniences are within reach. To the west, enjoy the proximity to a public walking trail, ideal for recreation and relaxation. The eastern boundary features two neighbors, while expansive farmland lies just beyond the trail to the west, providing picturesque views and a sense of open space. Whether you're looking to build your dream home or invest in land, this property combines nature, convenience, and potential.

00 N Main Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Listwithfreedom.com.

$105,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Motivated Seller! Welcome home to comfort, convenience, and a location that truly has it all! This cozy 2-bedroom, 1 full bath home offers over 1,000 square feet of inviting living space-perfect for anyone looking to simplify without sacrificing accessibility. Situated near Riley Elementary School, New Castle Middle School, and New Castle High School, this home makes daily routines a breeze. Enjoy being close to it all, including outdoor fun at Baker Park, refreshing summer days at the local public pool, and a variety of nearby shopping and dining options. Inside, you'll find a warm and functional layout with comfortable living spaces and plenty of natural light. The unfinished basement offers excellent storage or the potential for future use, while the fully fenced backyard provides privacy-perfect for relaxing evenings, pets, or entertaining. Whether you're starting out, downsizing, or investing, this home is a fantastic opportunity in a prime location!

3015 S Main Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$339,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome home to 402 Luellen Drive, a brand-new gem crafted by Bridgenorth Homes. Showcasing the highly sought-after Bristol floor plan, this 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom residence offers 1,469 square feet of beautifully designed, functional living space. Step through the arched entryway and into a bright, inviting open-concept layout bathed in natural light from an abundance of windows. The spacious living area flows seamlessly with the dining room and a modern kitchen built for entertaining. The kitchen features sleek solid surface countertops, an undermount sink, a walk-in pantry, and a large center island with bar seating. Just off the dining area, you'll find a covered porch-the perfect spot for enjoying your morning coffee or winding down in the evening.The smart split-bedroom floor plan ensures privacy. The primary suite serves as a true retreat, boasting a generous walk-in closet and a beautiful en suite bathroom complete with a vanity and zero-entry shower. Two additional spacious bedrooms share a beautifully appointed second full bathroom. Additional interior highlights include a separate, dedicated laundry room for everyday convenience and a massive 3-car attached garage providing ample space for vehicles, storage, or a workshop. Located in a lovely, newly developed community, residents enjoy access to a brand-new clubhouse, walking trails, and close proximity to the local YMCA. Don't miss your chance to be the very first owner of this pristine home!

402 Luellen Way, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$265,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Check out this completely updated home near Riley Elementary. 3 Bedrooms, 2 bath ranch home. Updated kitchen with appliances. Attached garage, Privacy fenced yard with large storage shed. Immediate possession.

1127 Hickory Lane, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$279,999
This beautiful building in New Castle's Historic District is available for you to make your own! Main floor retail area, studio apt and 2 BR apt all currently leased. Great location in the heart of a busy downtown. Own parking lot and new HVAC system in '24. Main floor retail property to be shown only during business hours: 9a-5:30p M-F. 9a-12 noon Sat. Main floor retail business not for sale. Located in Historic District - restrictions apply, these are located in associated documents.

208 S Main Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$529,900
Looking to build residential or commercial? 31 acres give you the country feel yet close to town and main thoroughfares. 27/31 acres are tillable with a 2 acre pond . Possibilities are endless.

000 S State Road 103, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$19,900
N 28th St is a street platted but never developed. The owner is currently in negotiations with the city and his neighbors to vacate the alley. 3 city lots each measuring 70x131 for a grand total of 0.632 Acres. City water and sewer available but not connected. Electricity from Duke Energy and Gas from CenterPoint available but not connected. Lots will not be divided.

000 N 28th Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$149,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
This single-family residence in Henry County presents an opportunity to own a home and create your own story. The residence includes three bedrooms, providing personal space and comfort. Property offers a quaint living area, built on a generous lot almost a quarter of an acre, providing ample room for outdoor activities and relaxation. Constructed in 1957, this single-story home offers a unique opportunity, loaded with potential. Concessions Available. Call Agent.

2517 S 23rd Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Trusted Realty Partners of Ind.

$89,700
Looking for more space, stunning views, and the freedom to build your dream home? Welcome to Meadowbrook Ridge a new subdivision located on Spiceland Pike and Meadowbrook Drive. Set on gently rolling ground, this neighborhood features larger-than-average lots with valley views and unforgettable sunsets. It's the perfect mix of peaceful surroundings and everyday convenience. * City utilities are available * Minutes from schools, shopping, and dining * Quick access to SR 3 and I-70 * Choose your own builder Whether you're ready to build now or planning for the future, Meadowbrook Ridge offers the flexibility and setting to make it happen. Come walk the land and picture the possibilities.

***7 S Spiceland Pike, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$93,600
Looking for more space, stunning views, and the freedom to build your dream home? Welcome to Meadowbrook Ridge a new subdivision located on Spiceland Pike and Meadowbrook Drive. Set on gently rolling ground, this neighborhood features larger-than-average lots with valley views and unforgettable sunsets. It's the perfect mix of peaceful surroundings and everyday convenience. City utilities are available Minutes from schools, shopping, and dining Quick access to SR 3 and I-70 Choose your own builder Whether you're ready to build now or planning for the future, Meadowbrook Ridge offers the flexibility and setting to make it happen. Come walk the land and picture the possibilities.

**10 Meadowbrook Drive, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$43,550
Looking for more space, stunning views, and the freedom to build your dream home? Welcome to Meadowbrook Ridge a new subdivision located on Spiceland Pike and Meadowbrook Drive. Set on gently rolling ground, this neighborhood features larger-than-average lots with valley views and unforgettable sunsets. It's the perfect mix of peaceful surroundings and everyday convenience. * City utilities are available * Minutes from schools, shopping, and dining * Quick access to SR 3 and I-70 * Choose your own builder Whether you're ready to build now or planning for the future, Meadowbrook Ridge offers the flexibility and setting to make it happen. Come walk the land and picture the possibilities.

***4 Meadowbrook Drive, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$47,450
Looking for more space, stunning views, and the freedom to build your dream home? Welcome to Meadowbrook Ridge a new subdivision located on Spiceland Pike and Meadowbrook Drive. Set on gently rolling ground, this neighborhood features larger-than-average lots with valley views and unforgettable sunsets. It's the perfect mix of peaceful surroundings and everyday convenience. City utilities are available Minutes from schools, shopping, and dining Quick access to SR 3 and I-70 Choose your own builder Whether you're ready to build now or planning for the future, Meadowbrook Ridge offers the flexibility and setting to make it happen. Come walk the land and picture the possibilities.

***6 Meadowbrook Drive, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$58,500
Looking for more space, stunning views, and the freedom to build your dream home? Welcome to Meadowbrook Ridge a new subdivision located on Spiceland Pike and Meadowbrook Drive. Set on gently rolling ground, this neighborhood features larger-than-average lots with valley views and unforgettable sunsets. It's the perfect mix of peaceful surroundings and everyday convenience. City utilities are available Minutes from schools, shopping, and dining Quick access to SR 3 and I-70 Choose your own builder Whether you're ready to build now or planning for the future, Meadowbrook Ridge offers the flexibility and setting to make it happen. Come walk the land and picture the possibilities.

***8 Meadowbrook Drive, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$61,750
Looking for more space, stunning views, and the freedom to build your dream home? Welcome to Meadowbrook Ridge a new subdivision located on Spiceland Pike and Meadowbrook Drive. Set on gently rolling ground, this neighborhood features larger-than-average lots with valley views and unforgettable sunsets. It's the perfect mix of peaceful surroundings and everyday convenience. * City utilities are available * Minutes from schools, shopping, and dining * Quick access to SR 3 and I-70 * Choose your own builder Whether you're ready to build now or planning for the future, Meadowbrook Ridge offers the flexibility and setting to make it happen. Come walk the land and picture the possibilities.

***9 S Spiceland Pike, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$160,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
This fully renovated 1850 SqFt, 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom two-story home is located in a quiet neighborhood and offers modern updates with charming natural woodwork throughout. The spacious kitchen features a large center island perfect for morning gatherings and coffee, along with all brand-new appliances, while a bonus room on the main level provides flexibility for an office or playroom. The large lot and backyard offer plenty of space, with room to add a garage if desired. The basement is fully insulated, offering additional storage or recreational space. With everything in the home brand new, it's move-in ready and full of possibilities.

1404 S 23rd Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Mark Dietel Realty, LLC.

$899,900
This 44+/- acre property offers a prime location with significant potential for commercial development. Featuring a large amount of frontage along State Road 3, along with convenient rail access, this parcel is perfectly situated for a variety of business ventures. Previously part of a large farming operation, the land is surrounded by other commercial enterprises, making it an ideal candidate for similar development. The property is well-equipped for future use, with high-pressure gas lines and a nearby substation providing ample power to support any commercial or industrial operations. This rare opportunity combines accessibility, utilities, and location, offering an excellent foundation for your next enterprise. Don't miss your chance to secure this exceptional piece of real estate in central Indiana.

N State Road 3, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$631,500
City water and sewer connection available! Private well already onsite. Prime Location! Take advantage of this rare opportunity to purchase this 2.5 acre lot with endless potential! Approximately 400' of State Road 3 Road Frontage. Surrounded on all four sides by road frontage makes accessibility ideal. Electric and Gas available for connection.

4200 S Memorial Drive, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$129,900
Nice corner lot on busy downtown street. Great for retail or service. Owner will build to suit.* A new parcel will be created for approx. 100'x100' lot. ***Seller is Licensed Real Estate Agent**

400 S 14th Street S, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative