Luxury Homes Worth Every Look
Handpicked estates, waterfront retreats, golf-course residences, and private acreage — all priced from $1.7M to $1.95M across the Indianapolis metro.
The Greater Indianapolis luxury market is delivering remarkable variety right now.
From Chatham Hills golf estates in Westfield to waterfront retreats on Geist Reservoir, a 200-acre lodge in Scott County, and boutique single-level condominiums steps from Carmel's Monon Trail — the listings below represent some of the most compelling properties on the market today. I'm Liz Marks-Strauss with FC Tucker Company, and I'm here to help you navigate every one of them. Call me at 317-502-3358 or email LizMS@TalkToTucker.com — I'd love to schedule a showing.
WestfieldStunning open-concept living with great views, soaring rooms, and designer finishes. The Great Room features 14' shiplap coffered ceiling open to a pro-kitchen with walk-in pantry. A finished walkout basement adds entertainment area, bar, game room, wine room, and exercise space. 4-car attached garage with epoxy floor; pond patio out back.
Scottsburg · 200 AcresA 200-acre private retreat — hand-hewn Oregon log lodge with 6,826 sq ft under roof, Brazilian walnut floors, and a breathtaking 15-acre lake at the property's heart. Wooded timberland, grassland meadow, and direct access to the Knobstone Trail make this a rare legacy property.
Geist ReservoirPositioned on the main body of Geist Reservoir — 6,700 sq ft waterfront estate with walls of picture windows framing the water like a living painting. Direct reservoir access, two-level boat storage, inground gunite pool, two primary suites, and every major upgrade already done. Come live it.
Chatham HillsA Chatham Gallery home set on over half an acre with private mature wooded views. Located in the evolving Chatham Hills community, featuring one of Indiana's best golf venues surrounded by natural landscapes and exquisite amenities. Ready for your arrival.
Lebanon · Private Acres FC TuckerCustom ranch on 4.5+ gated, private acres. Open-concept with hardwood floors, wood beams, luxury kitchen with large island, and a 3-car oversized garage. The standout feature: a finished, climate-controlled 3,600 sq ft Pole Barn with epoxy floors, 14' doors, full bath, laundry, and bonus room. Near I-65 for easy commuting.
Carmel · WestClayOver $350,000 in recent upgrades shine in this Village of WestClay custom home — notably a resort-inspired private courtyard with luxury plunge pool, hot tub, and curated patio. AGA custom range, built-in refrigerator, smart-home technology, whole-house generator, and a finished lower level with theater and custom bar round out this extraordinary lifestyle home.
Indianapolis · Geist AreaCustom Gary Nance design on 1.5+ wooded acres near Geist. Approx. 11,000 sq ft with inlaid hardwood floors, 20-ft soaring ceilings, inground pool, pool house, two home offices, wine cellar, and two bars. The entertainer's dream — five-car garage with room for your boat, too. Buyer allowances for appliances and AV systems included.
Bargersville · New 2025Brand-new 2025 Duke Homes custom build in Aberdeen at Bargersville — move-in ready today. Modern industrial architecture meets chef's kitchen with prep area, waterfall-edge granite island, and WiFi-enabled appliances. Each of 5 bedrooms has a private bath and walk-in closet. 4-car epoxy garage, ¾-acre lot with countryside views.
Zionsville · New Build FC TuckerCustom Nolan Schafer ranch-and-barn on 4.75 wooded acres in coveted Zionsville. Main level offers 2,736 sq ft of soaring ceilings and designer kitchen; lower level features full kitchen, theater, fitness room, and private bedroom suite. Plus — a barn. Near Anson shopping and Zionsville Village. Customize every finish with the builder.
Zionsville · 2 AcresNearly 2-acre lot in charming Zionsville — a fiberglass saltwater pool, oversized backyard, gas range with dual dishwashers, and over $500,000 invested in a complete overhaul. Basement sauna, landscape lighting, top-rated schools, and small-town convenience all wrapped in one beautifully reimagined home.
Sheridan · 12.9 AcresA true storybook estate on 12.92 acres — gated entry, spring-fed pond, stocked pond, equestrian barn, Mail Pouch barn, inground fiberglass pool, and an organic vegetable garden. Inside: a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, spa-like master suite, full finished basement with kitchen, and a Generac whole-home generator. Horses welcome.
Whitestown · 10 Acres FC Tucker10 heavily wooded acres overlooking Fishback Creek — bluff views, deciduous canopy, and incredible seclusion. A 4BR ranch with granite counters and new carpet sits near the center of the property. A 6-car detached garage with oil heater provides exceptional utility. In Zionsville school district, 1 mile from Stonegate Elementary and Zionsville West MS.
West Lafayette · Wabash RiverA private resort on 9+ wooded acres overlooking the Wabash River. Mid-century modern ranch with floor-to-ceiling windows, oak hardwood floors, indoor 50,000-gallon pool pavilion paneled in stunning Redwood, sauna, hot tub, and racquetball/pickleball court. Minutes from Purdue. A once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
Chatham Hills · Golf CourseNew Foxlane Homes build set against championship golf at Chatham Hills. Two-story great room, chef kitchen with commercial-grade appliances and hidden walk-in pantry, outdoor kitchen with fireplace, main-level primary suite, and a glass-enclosed bourbon bar in the finished lower level. Pure Westfield luxury with resort amenities at your door.
Westfield · Under ConstructionRegal Custom Homes 2026 new construction in Chatham Hills with pond views — 5 bedrooms, 4.5 baths, 6,500 total sq ft. Main-level primary suite, engineered hardwood floors, great-room fireplace, chef kitchen, covered porch, and a finished lower level with exercise room. Access to all Chatham Hills amenities including golf, pool, and pickleball.
Carmel · Monon TrailExclusive single-level luxury boutique collection (11 residences total) steps from the Monon Trail. Concrete and steel construction, 10-ft ceilings, Sub-Zero and Wolf appliances, natural stone and quartzite surfaces. Private fitness center, club room, outdoor fireplace, and secure parking. Walk to Carmel's Arts District, dining, and shopping.
Chatham Hills · RanchRegal Custom Homes ranch in Chatham Hills — 5,228 finished sq ft on a pond-view homesite. One-level luxury with vaulted great room, chef kitchen, private office, main-level primary suite, covered porch and patio. Lower level adds two bedrooms, exercise room, and 9'+ ceilings. Westfield-Washington Schools. Build in progress.
Liz Marks-Strauss
REALTOR® · FC Tucker Company · HeyMomImHome.com