Greater Indianapolis Luxury Real Estate · October 2026
Indianapolis Luxury Homes for Sale: 30 Estates from $1.95M to $2.25M
This month's collection covers Geist waterfront, golf-course living in Carmel, Westfield and Zionsville, a Mass Ave penthouse, and country estates on up to 200 acres. These are 30 of the region's luxury homes for sale, presented by Liz Marks-Strauss of F.C. Tucker Company.
- 30Homes featured
- $1.95M–$2.25MPrice range
- 7F.C. Tucker listings
- Up to 200Acres
Central Indiana's luxury market offers a lot for the money. Around $2 million here buys a home on Geist Reservoir, a new build in Holliday Farms, a skyline penthouse on Mass Ave, or a log estate on 100+ acres of timber and pasture. Every home below is priced between $1,949,900 and $2,250,000. I've sorted them by lifestyle so you can go straight to the setting you want.
Click any photo or address to see the full listing, with every photo, room details, taxes and the latest status. If something catches your eye, call or text me, Liz Marks-Strauss, at 317-502-3358 or email LizMS@TalkToTucker.com, and I'll set up a private showing.
Waterfront and Golf-Course Estates
If you want to wake up to Geist Reservoir, a fairway, or a quiet lake, start here. These homes sit in some of Central Indiana's most sought-after lake and club communities, including Geist, Holliday Farms, Chatham Hills, The Bridgewater Club and the Hawthorns.
$2,199,800
9652 Nautilus Circle
Indianapolis, Indiana
- 6 Beds
- 5 Baths
Main-body Geist waterfront on 150 feet of shoreline, with roughly 6,383 sq ft, a 14-foot great room framed by walls of windows, and Hamilton Southeastern Schools.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Allen Williams. Berkshire Hathaway Home
$2,099,900
12162 Pearl Bay Ridge
Indianapolis, Indiana
- 6 Beds
- 6 Baths
An all-brick Geist Reservoir estate with water and pool views from nearly every room, two main-floor bedrooms, and a kitchen updated in 2024.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Deborah Minth. United Real Estate Indpls
$2,000,000
7800 N Lakewood Drive
Unionville, Indiana
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
Lake Lemon frontage with walls of windows pulling the water into every living space and a main level built entirely for entertaining.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Alexis Cowan. Trueblood Real Estate
$2,249,000
10880 Dartmoor Court
Zionsville, Indiana
- 5 Beds
- 5 Baths
HBN's brand-new "Greer" on a quiet cul-de-sac in Holliday Farms: 12-foot coffered great room, custom inset cabinetry, an oversized scullery and a wet bar.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of John Stone. Blubird Real Estate
$2,249,000
20874 Promontory Lane
Westfield, Indiana
- 6 Beds
- 6 Baths
A Rise Builders home in Chatham Hills with wooded and creek views, a limestone entry, full brick wainscoting and 12-foot great-room ceilings.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Lance Cleland. The Agency Indy
$2,000,000
15479 Hidden Oaks Lane
Carmel, Indiana
- 6 Beds
- 6 Baths
Gated Hidden Oaks at The Bridgewater Club, overlooking Hole #7: 8,500+ sq ft, German-smear brick, a remodeled kitchen and a floor-to-ceiling glass wine display.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Kevin Fertig. Real Broker, LLC
$2,049,000
12121 Wetland Point
Fishers, Indiana
- 5 Beds
- 5 Baths
A Gradison-built Craftsman with nearly 10,000 sq ft on a wooded 0.76-acre lot in Hamilton Proper (Hawthorns CC), with a theater room and a finished daylight basement.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Scott Hackman. CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Signature Homes in Carmel, Zionsville, Westfield and Indianapolis
These homes keep you close to downtown Carmel, the Village of Zionsville, Mass Ave or Meridian Hills. The list includes a downtown Indianapolis penthouse, an Arden estate, a Williams Creek French manor, and a Carmel build where you still pick the finishes.
$2,200,000
14038 Salsbury Creek Drives
Carmel, Indiana
- 7 Beds
- 8 Baths
Resort-style Carmel living: a half-moon drive, heated in-ground pool, sunroom, two-sided fireplace and a gourmet kitchen with double ovens.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Chizuki Lothamer. @properties
$2,095,000
545 2nd Avenue NE
Carmel, Indiana
- 6 Beds
- 5 Baths
A newer Southern Colonial a short walk from downtown Carmel, with double front porches, gas lanterns, hardwood floors and a light-filled sunroom.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Carrie Holle. Compass Indiana, LLC
$1,965,000
1460 E Greyhound Pass
Carmel, Indiana
- 4 Beds
- 6 Baths
A custom-caliber Winget Homes build on a wooded ~0.91-acre Carmel homesite. Buyers can still choose finishes in this 6,900+ sq ft home with ceilings near 17 feet.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Tyler Winget. Circle Real Estate
$2,100,000
4509 Austin Oaks Court
Zionsville, Indiana
- 5 Beds
- 7 Baths
More than 12,000 sq ft close to everything in Zionsville: a two-story entry, four fireplaces, a butler's pantry, a den/library and a 1,154 sq ft garage.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Stan Comer. Carpenter, REALTORS®
F.C. Tucker Listing
$2,099,500
7951 Meridian Hills Lane
Indianapolis, Indiana
- 4 Beds
- 5 Baths
An O.C. Winters-designed French estate in Williams Creek Estates, extensively remodeled, with a marble Hollywood Regency foyer and herringbone floors.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Bif Ward. F.C. Tucker Company
F.C. Tucker Listing
$1,974,900
110 Bow Lane
Indianapolis, Indiana
- 5 Beds
- 7 Baths
Over 8,000 sq ft in Arden, entered through 750-pound cast-iron doors salvaged from a Chicago mansion. All five bedrooms have their own ensuite.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Matt McLaughlin. F.C. Tucker Company
F.C. Tucker Listing
$2,000,000
333 Massachusetts Avenue
Indianapolis, Indiana
- 3 Beds
- 4 Baths
A 3-bed, 3.5-bath Mass Ave penthouse with 4,300+ sq ft inside, a 1,300 sq ft skyline terrace, twin marble islands and Wolf, Miele and Sub-Zero appliances.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Jeff Carroll. F.C. Tucker Company
$1,949,900
2951 E 216th Street
Westfield, Indiana
- 4 Beds
- 5 Baths
A private 3-acre Westfield retreat: a Craftsman ranch with more than 6,000 finished sq ft and a 23x22 vaulted great room with fireplace.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Scott Hackman. CENTURY 21 Scheetz
F.C. Tucker Listing
$2,100,000
8264 W Fall Creek Drive
Pendleton, Indiana
- 4 Beds
- 6 Baths
A custom luxury ranch overlooking a pond and fountain, with a gated entry, a porte-cochère, stone-and-brick construction and 4.5 baths.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Deborah Elliott. F.C. Tucker Company
$2,150,000
4025 Lochview Court
Bargersville, Indiana
- 5 Beds
- 6 Baths
A Home-A-Rama custom by Rick Campbell Builder on a premier pond-view lot in Aberdeen, with a main-level primary suite and a finished daylight basement.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Amanda Johnson. CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Acreage Estates and Country Retreats
Room to breathe, sometimes a lot of it. These properties run from 1.5 to 200 acres and include log estates near Traders Point, working farmland, private fishing lakes and riverfront timberland, many within an easy drive of Indianapolis.
F.C. Tucker Listing
$2,100,000
7980-7984 Royal Avenue
Zionsville, Indiana
- 8 Beds
- 8 Baths
A renovated 12.3-acre Zionsville estate with no HOA, a pole barn and a pond, plus a second renovated home on an adjacent parcel that is currently leased.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Kim Barber. F.C. Tucker Company
F.C. Tucker Listing
$1,995,000
4480 W 121st Street
Zionsville, Indiana
- 4 Beds
- 6 Baths
A Georgian residence on four acres, designed by Steve Goldberg and built by Lawrence & Reckel, with a sweeping circular drive and custom built-ins.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Bif Ward. F.C. Tucker Company
F.C. Tucker Listing
$1,950,000
9102 W 82nd Street
Indianapolis, Indiana
- 4 Beds
- 4 Baths
A professionally designed log estate on 2.67 rolling acres near Traders Point, with floor-to-ceiling windows across the back. It is still within Indianapolis.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Matthew Kressley. F.C. Tucker Company
$2,000,000
7740 W 88th Street
Indianapolis, Indiana
- 1 Beds
- 2 Baths
12.8 acres of rolling, elevated land in Traders Point, suited to a custom home with a natural walkout. The neighboring property is to stay undeveloped.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Tim O'Connor. Berkshire Hathaway Home
$1,999,000
720 E 400 N
Anderson, Indiana
- 5 Beds
- 5 Baths
A legacy estate on 82.46 acres in North Anderson, styled after a Colorado mountain retreat, with nearly 6,000 sq ft. Recently price-improved.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Daniel Hubbard. eXp Realty LLC
$1,999,999
637 E 600 S
Trafalgar, Indiana
- 3 Beds
- 3 Baths
A custom log home with a walkout basement on 62+ meticulously kept acres in southern Johnson County, with three ponds and winding creeks.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Khloe Anderson. Land Pro Realty
$1,950,000
3917 N 525 W
Fairland, Indiana
- 6 Beds
- 5 Baths
A 10-acre estate on Snail Creek, more than a quarter-mile off the road, with 10,000+ sq ft and six bedrooms, about 35 minutes from downtown Indy.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Mark Miller. Vintage Realty, Inc
$1,950,000
21612 Dunbar Road
Sheridan, Indiana
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
Fifteen acres held by one family for 78 years, with a private stocked fishing lake, a barn and a 3-car detached garage. The home is sold as-is.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Sana Fakhoury. Trueblood Real Estate
$1,995,000
3073 N 800 W
Greenfield, Indiana
- 5 Beds
- 3 Baths
A brick ranch on 4.98 acres with a climate-controlled 45x60 shop. It adjoins 16.7+ more acres with barns, for 21.6 contiguous acres in total.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Jeffrey Turner. New Horizon Real Estate
$2,250,000
1555 Sieboldt Quarry Road
Springville, Indiana
- 3 Beds
- 4 Baths
A 2013 contemporary on 10+ acres, with a flat roof, Indiana limestone and stucco, two primary suites and roughly 5,100 sq ft.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Sarah Hamilton. Carpenter, REALTORS®
$2,250,000
920 W County Road 300 S
North Vernon, Indiana
- 4 Beds
- 4 Baths
A log-timber home on 111 acres along the Muscatatuck River, with a 55-foot saltwater pool, tillable acreage, ponds, trails and an off-grid hunting cabin.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Brad Garrison. Whitetail Properties
$1,950,000
3403 N Lino Lane
Scottsburg, Indiana
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
A 200-acre retreat with a hand-hewn Oregon-log lodge (6,826 sq ft under roof) overlooking a private lake, set more than half a mile off the road.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Jared Baird. Landproz of Indiana, LLC
$2,000,000
709 S Wynnwood Lane
Bloomington, Indiana
- 4 Beds
- 7 Baths
Nearly 13,000 sq ft on 1.55 wooded acres in Bloomington, with five fireplaces, an ensuite for every bedroom, and separate his-and-hers baths and closets in the primary suite.
View Listing Details →Listing courtesy of Tammy Druckemiller. RE/MAX Acclaimed Properties
Indianapolis Luxury Homes: Frequently Asked Questions
What do luxury homes in the Indianapolis area cost right now?
The 30 homes in this October 2026 roundup are priced between $1,949,900 and $2,250,000. In that range you'll find Geist waterfront homes, golf-community estates in Westfield, Carmel and Zionsville, a Mass Ave penthouse, and country properties on as much as 200 acres.
Which Indianapolis suburbs have the most luxury listings?
Carmel, Zionsville and Westfield appear most often in this collection, followed by Geist-area waterfront and the Traders Point and Williams Creek areas inside Indianapolis. Fishers, Pendleton and Bargersville are also represented.
Can I tour a luxury home that is listed by another brokerage?
Yes. Liz Marks-Strauss with F.C. Tucker Company can show you any home in this collection, whoever the listing brokerage is, and represent you as your buyer's agent. Call or text 317-502-3358 or email LizMS@TalkToTucker.com.
Are there luxury homes with acreage near Indianapolis?
Yes. More than a dozen homes in this roundup sit on 1.5 to 200 acres. They include 12.3 acres in Zionsville, 12.8 acres in Traders Point, 82 acres in Anderson, 62 acres in Trafalgar, and riverfront and lakefront retreats farther south.
Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Prices, availability and details are as of October 13, 2026 and are subject to change, so check the linked listing for current status. Listings are courtesy of the brokerages noted on each property. Liz Marks-Strauss, REALTOR®, F.C. Tucker Company · 317-502-3358 · LizMS@TalkToTucker.com · www.HeyMomImHome.com