Luxury Market Roundup · October 21, 2026

Indianapolis-Area Luxury Homes for Sale: 30 Estates from $1.95M to $2.3M

Geist waterfront, Carmel and Westfield golf communities, Zionsville acreage and country estates across Central Indiana, presented by Liz Marks-Strauss of FC Tucker Company.

Around $2 million, the Greater Indianapolis luxury market offers an unusual amount of choice. On Geist Reservoir, that buys main-body waterfront with long views across the water. In Hamilton County, it means homes in Chatham Hills, Bridgewater Club and Hamilton Proper, or a new-construction Southern Colonial in downtown Carmel. Zionsville adds Holliday Farms new builds and country acreage, while buyers who want land will find equestrian, timber and lake properties from Morgantown to Sheridan.

Here are 30 homes for sale right now, grouped by area. Tap any photo or address for full details, or call Liz Marks-Strauss at 317-502-3358 to schedule a showing.

30 luxury homes $1,950,000 to $2,295,000 12 recent price reductions $62.9M combined list value

Carmel, Westfield, Fishers & Sheridan (8)

Hamilton County's golf communities, gated enclaves and downtown Carmel.

Zionsville & Traders Point (6)

Holliday Farms new construction, country acreage and a rare rolling parcel in Traders Point.

Indianapolis: Geist, Williams Creek, Arden & Downtown (6)

Main-body Geist waterfront, classic estates and a Mass Ave penthouse.

Johnson & Morgan Counties (5)

Bargersville customs plus equestrian, timber and farm acreage to the south.

637 E 600 S, Trafalgar, IN luxury home for sale
$1,999,999

637 E 600 S, Trafalgar, IN

3 Beds3 Baths
62+ acres · southern Johnson County

A meticulously planned and maintained property that is as functional as it is beautiful.

Listing courtesy of Khloe Anderson, Land Pro Realty

View Listing Details →

Pendleton, Anderson & Greenfield (3)

Ranch living and big acreage east of the city.

Bloomington Area & Southern Indiana (2)

A Lake Lemon home and a modern estate near Springville.

Looking for a Luxury Home in Central Indiana?

Whether one of these homes caught your eye or you want a search built around water, acreage, golf or a specific community, Liz Marks-Strauss of FC Tucker Company can help you find the right fit.

Liz Marks-Strauss · FC Tucker Company
Call or text 317-502-3358 · Email LizMS@TalkToTucker.com

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and is subject to change, prior sale or withdrawal. Prices, features and status reflect MLS data available on October 21, 2026. Each property is listed by the brokerage shown on its card. Equal Housing Opportunity.