Greater Indianapolis · Luxury Real Estate
Greater Indianapolis Luxury Homes for Sale: 30 Featured Listings Over $2.4 Million
From custom estates in Carmel and Zionsville to golf-community homes in Westfield and waterfront retreats on Geist Reservoir, Greater Indianapolis offers some of the Midwest's finest luxury living. Here are 30 currently available homes priced above $2.4 million, hand-pulled from the live MLS.
Whether you're drawn to a gated estate in West Carmel, a golf-course home in Chatham Hills or Holliday Farms, a Geist Reservoir waterfront in Fishers, or a sprawling acreage retreat beyond the city, this collection showcases the top of the Greater Indianapolis luxury market. Every property below links straight to full photos, details, and current pricing. Ready for a private showing? Reach Liz Marks-Strauss directly at 317-502-3358 or LizMS@TalkToTucker.com.
Featured Luxury Listings
$3,795,000
14300 Oakbrook Court, Carmel, IN
5 Beds · 8 Baths
An exceptional custom estate on a seven-acre cul-de-sac homesite in the prestigious Oakbrook enclave, with a gunite pool, slate patio, and pool house.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,775,000
11710 Cold Creek Court, Zionsville, IN
5 Beds · 8 Baths
Over 10,000 sq ft in the gated Waterfront of West Clay, with two primary suites, a glass elevator, indoor basketball court, theatre, and 10+ garage spaces.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,650,000
1621 Chatham Ridge Court, Westfield, IN
5 Beds · 7 Baths
A walkout lot with golf-course views in Chatham, with 12-ft ceilings, an outdoor kitchen with Phantom Screens, and a basement golf simulator.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,550,000
3300 W 106th Street, Carmel, IN
5 Beds · 8 Baths
Nearly five private wooded acres in West Carmel with a vaulted great room, travertine floors, Sub-Zero and Thermador kitchen, pool, and pool house.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,500,000
108 Chatham Hills Boulevard, Westfield, IN
5 Beds · 6 Baths
New construction by Becley Building Group along the 5th hole in Chatham Hills — nearly 9,000 sq ft with a golf simulator and covered lanai overlooking the…
View Listing & Photos →
$3,499,999
4023 Cedar Hills North Drive, Greenwood, IN
5 Beds · 7 Baths
A private 14,000+ sq ft Center Grove estate with two primary suites, sport pool, home theater, sauna, 6-car garage, and a 32x60 shop.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,425,000
1015 W 116th Street, Carmel, IN
6 Beds · 7 Baths
A 2.67-acre estate on Carmel's coveted 116th Street corridor with a chef's kitchen, vaulted dining room, private tennis court, and lush grounds.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,360,600
22006 Oak Ridge, Sheridan, IN
4 Beds · 3 Baths
Over 56 acres of prime agricultural farmland near Grand Park, with a 2,000 sq ft residence and outbuildings — significant investor upside.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,300,000
7183 Ellis Lake Road, Paragon, IN
3 Beds · 3 Baths
A 107-acre private retreat with a 15-16 acre lake, farmland, ATV trails, a grass runway and airplane hangar, plus a 2022-built main home and guest house.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,300,000
9280 Highpointe Lane, Zionsville, IN
5 Beds · 7 Baths
A proposed Goldberg-designed build on 2 acres in the Promontory of Zionsville, with the option of Holliday Farms or Chatham Hills memberships.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,299,000
3687 W 121st, Zionsville, IN
5 Beds · 7 Baths
A custom-built luxury estate with marble counters, two full kitchens, spray-foam insulation, resort-style pool, hot tub, and oversized 4-car garage.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,290,000
1504 N Park Avenue, Indianapolis, IN
8 Beds · 10 Baths
The historic VonHake-Rau Queen Anne in the Old Northside — renovated main home, carriage house, and a 4-car garage with a 1-bed apartment above.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,250,000
720 S Rangeline Road, Carmel, IN
3 Beds · 4 Baths
Carmel's highest private residence — a downtown penthouse with 23-ft ceilings, Dolby theater, a 2,000 sq ft rooftop terrace, swim spa, and skyline views.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,100,000
42 Monahan Road, Zionsville, IN
5 Beds · 7 Baths
A signature Leonard Watson estate on 2+ acres in Clifden Pond — 10,700+ sq ft with a wine cellar, walkout lower level, heated gunite pool, and spa.
View Listing & Photos →
$3,050,000
8313 Keeneland Road, Zionsville, IN
6 Beds · 5 Baths
"Fait Maison" — a handcrafted 2026 Home-A-Rama European farmhouse by Old Town Design Group on a wooded lakeside homesite in Saddleridge Estates.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,995,000
12544 Anchorage Way, Fishers, IN
6 Beds · 7 Baths
A gated main-body Geist Reservoir waterfront estate in Fishers (HSE schools), ~7,500 sq ft with a saltwater pool, spa, and retractable boathouse.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,990,000
510 Kessler Boulevard W, Indianapolis, IN
5 Beds · 8 Baths
A gated 10,000+ sq ft West Crows Nest chateau modernized in 2025 with smart-home automation, refinished pool, and climate-controlled space for 8+ cars.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,850,000
9214 Bluestone Circle, Indianapolis, IN
8 Beds · 10 Baths
New construction by JK Heritage Homes overlooking Geist Reservoir — 10,000+ sq ft, 16-ft accordion doors, speakeasy lounge, wine cellar, and bunk room.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,775,000
10725 Holliday Farms Boulevard, Zionsville, IN
5 Beds · 5 Baths
On the 11th hole of gated Holliday Farms — floor-to-ceiling windows, theater, bourbon room, outdoor kitchen, and access to world-class club amenities.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,695,000
920 W County Road 300 S, North Vernon, IN
4 Beds · 4 Baths
A log timber home on 111 acres along the Muscatatuck River with a saltwater pool, income-producing acreage, ponds, trails, and an off-grid hunting cabin.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,695,000
5854 Julep Drive, Zionsville, IN
5 Beds · 6 Baths
A Home-A-Rama custom home on a private wooded lot in Zionsville, with floor-to-ceiling windows, a prep kitchen, wet bar, and a 115" media area.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,599,000
2701 Oak Way Trace, Westfield, IN
5 Beds · 6 Baths
A newer custom estate in Oak Park Estates on nearly an acre, with an elevator, dual-island chef's kitchen, pool, and 5-car garage.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,595,000
13400 Cambridge Cove Way, Fishers, IN
6 Beds · 6 Baths
An original-owner Tom Grinslade custom on a deep-water peninsula lot in Cambridge on Geist, with main-body sunset views, golf simulator, and pool.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,500,000
18483 Mallery Road, Noblesville, IN
3 Beds · 2 Baths
A Noblesville property offered at $2,500,000 — contact Liz for full details and a private showing.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,499,999
2034 Dubois Road, Spencer, IN
5 Beds · 6 Baths
A 55-acre Owen County country estate with pastures, ponds, trails, an indoor riding arena, guest residence, pool, and a 125-ft suspension bridge.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,499,900
12650 Shorevista Drive, Indianapolis, IN
5 Beds · 5 Baths
A waterfront estate in Admirals Bay on Geist with French white oak floors, 20-ft fireplace, renovated spa baths, wine cellar, and a glass-enclosed spa.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,499,000
15876 Oak Park, Westfield, IN
5 Beds · 7 Baths
The final new-construction offering in Oak Park by Quality Homes by Brian Hayes — 7,000+ sq ft on a private .73-acre wooded homesite with a 5-car garage.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,475,000
307 E Small Street, Carmel, IN
5 Beds · 5 Baths
An Old Town Design Group custom in the Carmel Arts & Design District on a half-acre, with a chef's kitchen, screened porch, pool, and main-level in-law…
View Listing & Photos →
$2,450,000
7813 W 50 S, Morgantown, IN
4 Beds · 3 Baths
"Lost Creek Ranch" — an updated log cabin home on 30+ acres with two stocked ponds, trails, a custom waterfall, and a 65x37 four-stall horse barn.
View Listing & Photos →
$2,400,000
14950 Geist Ridge Drive, Fishers, IN
6 Beds · 7 Baths
A custom Craftsman by Dan Elliott on 2.89 wooded acres in Valleys of Geist, with a deeded boat dock, dual-island kitchen, attached ADU, and resort pool.
View Listing & Photos →Find Your Greater Indianapolis Luxury Home
Estates in Carmel, Zionsville, Westfield, and on Geist move quickly and often sell off-market. As a local expert with F.C. Tucker Company, Liz Marks-Strauss can arrange private showings, share off-market opportunities, and guide you through every step — buying or selling — across Greater Indianapolis.
Listings presented by Liz Marks-Strauss, F.C. Tucker Company, serving Greater Indianapolis. Properties shown are sourced from the local Multiple Listing Service (MIBOR) and may be listed by other brokerages; some results may include nearby Central/Southern Indiana communities. Availability and pricing are subject to change. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative. This is not a solicitation if your property is currently listed with another broker. Equal Housing Opportunity.