Shirley IN Homes For Sale

$45,000

3 parcels totaling 1.63 acres on N. Railroad Street in Shirley. Currently zoned R3. Utilities there/nearby ...Water line needs to be extended to property which Town of Shirley will do. There are connect fees.

N Railroad Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$160,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Located in Eastern Hancock School District a charming piece of history at 208 White Shirley. This single-family residence offers 976 square feet of comfortable living space, providing a unique opportunity to embrace a home with character and charm. Features two bedrooms with a dining room that is currently being used as a third bedroom and a large utility/laundry room at the back of the home. A charming sunroom offers additional living space filled with natural light. A spacious one-car garage provides parking along with additional room for storage. The fully fenced backyard is complemented by mature trees offering shade and a peaceful setting. Come see today!

208 N White Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of Carpenter, REALTORS®.

$499,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Ready to get away from it all? Tucked a half mile off the road on nearly 12 acres, this charming log home offers the perfect blend of privacy, natural beauty, and peaceful country living just one hour east of downtown Indianapolis. Step inside to a soaring cathedral ceiling and a stunning wood-burning fireplace that serves as the centerpiece of the inviting, open-concept living space. The main level features a spacious living room, kitchen, dining area, bedroom, full bath, and convenient laundry/mudroom. Upstairs, the spacious primary suite offers its own private full bath, complete with a relaxing soaking tub and separate walk-in shower. The walkout basement provides endless possibilities and is ready to be finished to suit your needs. It currently offers what could be a third bedroom space, roughed-in half bath, and generous recreation area. Step outside and take in the tranquility from the wraparound main-level deck, where beautiful natural views surround you in every direction. Approximately five acres of the property are wooded, creating a peaceful backdrop and plenty of opportunities to enjoy the outdoors. A 30' x 54' pole barn adds valuable storage and workspace, featuring two overhead doors. The nearly five acres of tillable land are currently cash rented, providing an additional opportunity for income. Whether you're looking for a private homestead, weekend getaway, or peaceful retreat, this one-of-a-kind property offers the space, seclusion, and natural beauty you've been searching for. Don't miss your opportunity to make this hidden gem your own!

7640 W County Road 350 S, Shirley

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

$759,900

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Beautiful 25-acre horse farm offering the space, setting, and usable improvements that are becoming harder to find. A long paved driveway bordered by fenced pasture creates a classic country entrance and leads to a well-kept 5-bedroom brick ranch with multiple living areas, a 4-season sunroom, and tasteful cosmetic updates throughout. The home offers a comfortable and functional layout with plenty of room to spread out. The kitchen features stainless appliances and an open design, while the family room provides a cozy fireplace and additional flexible living space. The land is the true standout. Nearly all 25 acres are fenced, making the property well-suited for horses, livestock, hobby farming, or buyers needing room for equipment, storage, and outdoor use. The farm includes multiple barns, including a barn with 6 stalls plus storage and a large 48x188 arena-style barn that was previously used for indoor riding. Open pasture, maintained grounds, and easy access throughout the property add to the overall usability. Located in the Eastern Hancock School District, this property offers a hard-to-find combination of acreage, fencing, barns, and a comfortable home, all with convenient access to I-70, Greenfield, Anderson, New Castle, and Indianapolis. A rare opportunity to own a well-cared-for small farm in a highly accessible location.

715 N White Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$109,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Welcome to this delightful, updated home in a quiet community, offering plenty of inviting, ready-to-move-in living space. This home is designed for comfortable and convenient living, presenting an opportunity to embrace a relaxed lifestyle. The home features two well-proportioned bedrooms, providing comfortable retreats for rest and privacy. A single full bathroom ensures all your daily needs are met with ease. All new HVAC systems have been installed. Adding to the home's appeal are practical amenities such as a dedicated laundry room, an attached carport & 2 car garage for convenient parking, a welcoming covered deck perfect for outdoor enjoyment, and a charming porch. The generous sized lot offers ample outdoor space. This inviting home provides a perfect blend of comfort and convenience, ready for you to make it your own. Close to schools, shopping and everything one needs!

608 White Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of Red Bridge Real Estate.

$500,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Discover a life of serene comfort at 7642 W County Road 350 S, Shirley, IN. Built in 2004, this inviting single-family residence, spanning 1200 square feet, is ready to welcome you home, offering a perfect blend of rustic and cabin charm. The heart of this home is undoubtedly its open kitchen, a space designed for both culinary exploration and casual gatherings. It features a convenient island, providing ample workspace and a natural focal point for the room. With two comfortable bedrooms and two full bathrooms, this single-story home provides practical living arrangements. Beyond the interiors, the property extends its living spaces outdoors. Enjoy the fresh air from the welcoming porch, or entertain guests on the spacious patio. For those seeking a sheltered outdoor experience, a covered patio offers protection from the elements. The extensive 508,781 square foot lot, just under 12 acres, also includes a private dock, offering direct access to your own stocked fishing pond. Present owner has created a family friendly park for both kids and and adults alike. The huge 4 stall garage is now now zoned as a Event Center and Restaurant. The Event Center and Restaurant zoning is already in place and the necessary infrastructure has been added, appealing to buyers looking for either a lifestyle property, a business opportunity, or both. A commercial grade septic system has been added to take care of the Event Center. A large 40x40' concrete slab has been added for other outdoor events. An area has been fenced off with vinyl snow fence and has been used for off road vehicle events. Embrace the lifestyle you've been dreaming of; schedule your private viewing of this exceptional property today.

7642 W County Road 350 S, Shirley

Listing courtesy of Lauck Real Estate Sevices, LLC.

$30,000

.51 acre corner lot

424 Pennsylvania Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of REMAX ONE.

$19,700

Total of 3 lots, approx total .39 AC wooded. Could be buildable lot if plans meet city guidelines. City utilities are believed to be close.

Pennsylvania Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of REMAX ONE.

$29,900

1/2-acre lot on the edge of town, previously farmed and ready for your next idea. Tucked on a dead-end street, this property offers minimal traffic and nice country views. Shirley town water is available up the street, and the town anticipates future sewer expansion. Located in northeastern Hancock County within the Eastern Hancock School District, and conveniently positioned between Greenfield, Anderson, and New Castle.

N Pennsylvania Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$119,999

SELLER SAYS MAKE THEM AN OFFER. BIG PRICE REDUCTION***A local landmark the DOOR STORE is up for sale! What an amazing opportunity for the entrepreneur who is always looking for additional opportunities. We are selling the building but giving you the business. What is here will stay here with the exception of some pending orders. Intrigued? Are you a woodworker or have a desire to be a woodworker? Maybe you just like to build cabinets or you like to flip houses. Maybe you want to set up an online store or keep the current setup with a storefront and sell the cabinet doors, trim etc. There are three addresses 305, 307 & 309. Two overhead garage doors. There are also 4 semi trailers behind the store that are stocked with EVEN MORE cabinet doors and shelving. These are not prefab these are REAL WOOD. Oak, Hickory, Birch oh my! This is a huge opportunity. There is NO AC but there are a couple furnaces and a hanging heater. Seller is selling as is. It is time for the sellers to step away and let someone else take the reins. If you have been on the fence about this opportunity, please reach out. So many opportunities await you. Seller indicates that there is three phase electrical. There is a bathroom but the sellers have never had water turned on so they cannot tell you if it works but they will not have the water turned on to test it. Roof was done by Five Star Commercial Roofing in 2012. Seller does have pending cabinet orders and will be completing those offers out of the stock there. Lot & BLDG Sq ft is approximate. 305, 307, 309 & 315 Main Street

305 Main Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of Home Loop Realty, LLC.

$29,900

Vacant lot totaling .51acres. Per area plan office this is a residential lot and could be buildable as long as improvement met all set back requirements. City utilities are nearby according to the City of Shirley.

Pennsylvania Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of Maximum Results Real Estate.

$29,900

Vacant lot totaling .51acres. Per area plan office this is a residential lot and could be buildable as long as improvement met all set back requirements. City utilities are nearby according to the City of Shirley.

0000 Pennsylvania Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of Maximum Results Real Estate.

$23,000

Empty lot on Main St. in Shirley. This lot is an open canvas for someone wanting to build or develop their own small-town business. The options are endless you just have make this yours and be creative.

314 Main Street, Shirley

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Real Estate Solutions.