Knightstown IN Homes For Sale

Wake up to lake views and fall asleep to the sounds of the woods. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom retreat sits on five wooded acres overlooking Lake Haven in Henry County, offering the rare combination of privacy, natural beauty, and lake access all in one property. Spend your mornings with coffee on the covered front porch, evenings entertaining on the side deck, and every season in between soaking up the view from the three-seasons room. With deer, birds, and other wildlife regularly passing through the property, this home feels like a year-round nature retreat - while the lake itself invites you to fish, paddle, or simply unwind on the water. Inside, the home offers a functional floor plan. The encapsulated attic presents a great opportunity to finish additional square footage for more living space down the road. Nearby, Knightstown has a charming small-town feel and a bit of Hollywood history as the home of the Hoosier Gym, made famous by the movie Hoosiers. If you've been searching for wooded acreage, lake living, and small-town charm within reach of Indianapolis, 5351 S Westwood Dr is a must-see.

5351 S Westwood, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of @properties.

$179,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

This is the perfect starter home or for someone looking to downsize. The property is located in the heart of Knightstown. This 1,396 Square foot, 3 bedroom ranch, on an oversized city lot, includes the following updates: New siding, new vinyl windows, new carpet, New AC unit, new shower surround, and even new concrete on the front steps and sidewalk.

223 W Brown Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$489,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Don't miss this opportunity! This home has been meticulously cared for, featuring yearly service contracts on the HVAC, plumbing, and water systems, alongside many other updates (see docs). Welcome to 5432 W Whittier Dr, where distinctive architecture and versatile space come together. This 2,160 sq. ft., 1.5-story A-frame home offers three bedrooms, two full baths, and a warm, rustic character that makes it feel anything but ordinary. The updated kitchen serves as the heart of the home and creates a natural connection to the dining room and living area. The dining room leads to sliding glass doors that open onto a new wraparound deck. The primary bedroom is flooded with natural light from the skylight, and the main bath features a Bluetooth-equipped exhaust fan. Don't miss the charming den tucked away in the back, complete with a wood-burning stove, a custom-built wet bar, and a Winchester safe that conveys with the house-the perfect space to unwind and retreat. For the buyer who needs serious workspace, the impressive 30' x 50' pole barn is a standout feature. Complete with a concrete floor, 200-amp service, and two 12' x 12' bay doors, this space offers incredible flexibility for vehicles, boats, hobbies, a workshop, or additional storage. A separate powered storage shed provides even more room to keep equipment, tools, and seasonal items organized. Best of all, Knightstown Lake is just minutes away, putting boating, fishing, kayaking, and days on the water within easy reach. Whether you're searching for a property with exceptional garage space, or a home that blends character with recreation and functionality, 5432 W Whittier Dr delivers something truly special. Move-in ready and filled with possibilities, this is more than a home-it's the lifestyle you've been looking for.

5432 W Whittier Drive, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Advantage, REALTOR.

$244,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

If you enjoy back porch sitting this is the perfect little spot for you. Front porch and a covered back porch perfect for lounging or entertaining. Home is light, bright and remodeled ready for you to call it home. Cute and quiet street with off street parking along with your two car detached garage. Though seller has never lived in the home he took great pride in making the home something to be proud of. New kitchen with quartz countertops, new cabinets, new stainless appliances and new luxury vinyl plank flooring. Floor joists above the basement were replaced with new block supports added. Furnace is 5 years old, new AC unit, new water heater and prior owner installed Bee windows throughout. New roof on the house and the garage. So many updates that you just need to come and see the home. Two full new baths and 4 bedrooms at this amazing price.

134 W Pine Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of Home Loop Realty, LLC.

$360,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Presenting an exceptional opportunity at 11597 N State Road 140, a single-family residence constructed in 1968, offering 1596 square feet of meticulously designed living space. This property distinguishes itself with a thoughtful layout and an expansive lot, providing both comfort and privacy. The residence encompasses three well-appointed bedrooms, offering versatile accommodations for residents and guests. Complementing these are two full bathrooms, each designed for functionality and ease of use. Spanning three distinct stories, this property offers a dynamic living experience, with each level contributing to the overall sense of space and flow. The substantial 30797 square foot lot provides ample outdoor potential, inviting a range of landscaping and recreational possibilities. Relax in your fully enclosed all seasons room or out by the pool enjoying the outdoors. We invite you to discover the full potential of this distinctive property through a private viewing.

11597 N State Road 140, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of The Modglin Group.

$119,900

INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY FOR RENTAL INCOME in KNIGHTSTOWN! Large home with FOUR LARGE UNITS, TWO CURRENTLY RENTED-- one bedroom, living room, kitchen, full bath, and laundry hook-ups in EACH UNIT, about 900 square feet in each unit! Nice yard for tenants to enjoy! Basement provides access to most mechanics! Enclosed front entry has foyer and stairs where tenants access each unit! Tenants pay all utilities, with separate meters for each unit! Current tenants are long-standing, faithful rent payers and good stewards of their units!

116 W Pine Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of The Michele Group.

$265,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Fall in love with the perfect blend of farmhouse charm and modern updates in this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home situated on over 2 beautiful acres in Knightstown! Offering peaceful country living with plenty of room to roam, this property is ideal for those looking to enjoy open space while benefiting from recent improvements. Inside, you'll find comfortable living spaces filled with character, enhanced by major system upgrades. New furnace and central air conditioning, new PEX plumbing, new appliances, and an energy-efficient tankless water heater, providing comfort and peace of mind for years to come. Outside, the expansive property offers endless possibilities for gardening, recreation, hobby farming, or simply enjoying the quiet countryside. Whether you're relaxing on the property or planning your next outdoor project, you'll appreciate the space and flexibility this home provides. If you've been searching for a move-in-ready farmhouse with modern mechanical updates and room to grow, this is one you won't want to miss!

11502 N Carthage Pike, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of The Fox Group Real Estate.

$375,000

2.5 COMMERICAL ACRES, with 29 UNIT STORAGE BUILDING! At I-70 Exit 115/SR 109! Adjacent to eastbound off ramp! New Henry Community Health Outpatient Center nearby! Already ZONED GENERAL BUSINESS/COMMERCIAL! Space for additional storage buildings on the 2.5 AC parcel! Also, 4.5 AC parcel for sale (still to be divided, hence, will receive new parcel numbers once completed.)

9020 W 650 S, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of The Michele Group.

$298,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Welcome home to 336 North Madison Street in Knightstown, where quality craftsmanship meets comfortable, modern living. This beautifully designed ranch offers nearly 1,500 square feet of thoughtfully planned living space with a desirable split-bedroom floor plan featuring three spacious bedrooms and two full baths. The heart of the home is the impressive 20' x 17' great room with a soaring vaulted ceiling, creating an open and inviting space for everyday living and entertaining. The adjoining kitchen is beautifully appointed with custom Amish-built hickory cabinetry, granite countertops, and stainless steel appliances, with matching granite finishes in both bathrooms for a cohesive, upscale look. The private primary suite is tucked away from the two additional bedrooms and hall bath, offering a peaceful retreat. A convenient laundry room, all-municipal utilities, total electric service with an energy-efficient heat pump, and quality finishes throughout make this home as practical as it is attractive. Step outside onto the rear deck, perfect for relaxing or entertaining, and enjoy the quiet neighborhood setting. The oversized 24' x 24' attached garage and concrete driveway provide plenty of room for vehicles, storage, and hobbies. Ideally located on a quiet street in the charming town of Knightstown, this home offers small-town living with exceptional convenience-just minutes from the I-70 interchange, making commuting to Indianapolis, Richmond, and surrounding communities quick and easy.

336 N Madison Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Realty Group.

$109,900

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Welcome home to this charming older residence located at 24 West Brown Street in Knightstown. Filled with character and lovingly maintained, this inviting home offers five comfortable rooms on the main level, including two bedrooms and a full bath, providing convenient one-level living. The partially finished second story presents exciting possibilities, with space for two additional bedrooms and a loft area-ideal for expanding your living space, creating a home office, or designing the retreat you've always envisioned. Outside, you'll find a well-maintained yard and a detached one-and-a-half-car garage, offering ample storage and workspace. Whether you're looking for your first home, downsizing, or searching for a property with room to grow, this delightful Knightstown home is full of potential and ready for its next chapter.

24 W Brown Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Realty Group.

$255,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Charm, character, and modern comfort come together in this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2 full-bath home offering approximately 2,000 square feet of inviting living space. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the beautifully landscaped yard that creates exceptional curb appeal and a warm first impression. Step inside to discover soaring vaulted ceilings that fill the home with natural light and create a bright, open atmosphere perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious floor plan offers comfortable gathering spaces while maintaining a welcoming feel throughout. The well-appointed kitchen flows seamlessly into the living areas, making it ideal for hosting family and friends. Four generously sized bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office, while two full bathrooms offer both convenience and comfort. Ideally located in the heart of Knightstown, this home offers the perfect blend of small-town charm and everyday convenience with easy access to local shops, dining, schools, and parks. If you're searching for a home that offers space, style, and outstanding curb appeal, this beautiful property is one you won't want to miss. Schedule your private showing today!

117 S Washington Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of Realty of America LLC.

$264,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Discover the charm and comfort of 225 E Jackson, a beautifully remodeled single-family residence in KNIGHTSTOWN, IN. Built in 1950. This is a cook's dream with 3 ovens and granite countertops. Soft close cabinet and vanity doors add to the luxurious feel. This house feels very open with 10' ceilings in living room and dining room and an 11' cathedral ceiling in master bedroom. You will love the 20 year commercial grade vinyl plank floors throughout. The owner did it right with all new plumbing and electrical. Relax and rejuvenate in one of the property's three full bathrooms, with a porcelain tub and high end commodes. The Jack and Jill bathroom on the second floor offers a spacious walk-in shower, providing a spa-like experience within the comfort of your home. This two-story residence also includes a convenient laundry room, simplifying daily chores and lots of conditioned attic storage space. New HVAC with a gas furnace makes for icy cold upstairs and down. Step outside to enjoy the inviting porch, perfect for morning coffee or evening relaxation, and gather around the fire pit for memorable evenings under the stars. Embrace the lifestyle awaiting you at this exceptional property; schedule your private viewing today.

225 E Jackson, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of Ever Real Estate, LLC.

$100,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Seller is selling in the home condition that you see it in and is priced to sell. Investor cash opportunity awaits in this spacious 5-bedroom home situated on a rare double lot in Knightstown! Due all your inspections before your offer. Offering an abundance of living space, this home provides plenty of room to spread out, entertain, or accommodate a growing household. Step onto the inviting wraparound front porch-the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind in the evening. Outside, you'll find a fully fenced backyard with ample space for pets, play, gardening, or outdoor gatherings, along with a detached two-car garage for additional parking and storage. Inside, the generous square footage offers endless possibilities to make the home your own. Whether you're dreaming of modern updates or simply adding your personal style, this home is full of potential and ready for its next chapter. If you've been searching for space, character, and a chance to create your dream home, this Knightstown property is one you won't want to miss!

211 S Washington Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of Homeward Bound Realty LLC.

$954,086

68.18 acres with 67.95 tillable acres. This nearly all-tillable farm consists of two highly productive fields, separated by a small mini farm owned by another landowner. Both fields are nearly square in shape, allowing for efficient farming operations. The north field borders Interstate 70, providing excellent accessibility and visibility. The farm is primarily made up of productive Crosby silt loam and Cyclone silty clay loam soils. With only 11.4 feet of elevation change across the entire property, the land lays exceptionally flat. Although located in Henry County, the farm is just one-half mile from the Hancock County line and only 2.5 miles from Eastern Hancock High School. This property offers the opportunity for a rural setting while still being conveniently located just 12 miles from Greenfield and 5.6 miles from Knightstown.

000 S County Road 1075 Road W, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of Landproz of Indiana, LLC.

$661,640

47.26 acres with 47.13 tillable acres. This highly productive farm carries a strong 156.5 Weighted Average Productivity Index (WAPI). The property offers approximately 940 feet of road frontage along County Road 850 South and 1,600 feet of frontage on County Road 1075 West, providing excellent access and future flexibility. The farm features a gentle roll with only 17 feet of elevation change across the property, allowing for efficient farming operations and good drainage. Although located in Henry County, the farm is just one-half mile from the Hancock County line and only 2.4 miles from Eastern Hancock High School. This property offers the opportunity for a rural setting while still being conveniently located just 11 miles from Greenfield and 4.6 miles from Knightstown.

000 W County Road 850 Road S, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of Landproz of Indiana, LLC.

$250,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

You can't build a 4 Bed, 3 Full Bath for this price point! Located in the heart of Knightstown, a city rich in history and Hoosier pride. This is where they filmed the movie! Primary on the Main with en suite Bath. Large 2nd Bed on the Main with another Full Bath next to it. All fully tiled showers. Beautiful! WIC and Ceiling Fans throughout. Kitchen is open to Living Room. Plenty of room for a Dining Table and Wraparound Couch. Coat closet and Pantry closet are there. Upstairs you will find two more bedrooms with a full bath. Upstairs has deck access. Two Car Attached Garage fully insulated and drywalled. Garage has two side areas, both are 20x8. One side has the W/H and Laundry Hook Up and plenty of room to add storage shelves. The other side could be an In-Home Office or area for Gym equipment. There is attic access for even more storage. Corner Lot with landscaping already started. Spend your time off relaxing instead of doing yardwork. Easy commute to I-70 and Indianapolis. 6 Minute drive to Royal Hylands Public GOLF Course. If you prefer fishing, kayaking or canoeing, Knightstown has two bodies of water that surround it. Henry Community Health is building a NEW HOSPITAL at the I-70/109 intersection. You can walk to restaurants and shopping on Main St. Everything is new from the studs to the roof!!

41 W Warrick Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of The Stewart Home Group.

$18,000

Discover a rare opportunity in Knightstown with this vacant corner lot, for your future home or investment. Measuring approximately 34 feet by 150 feet, this lot offers space for a variety of building possibilities. Enjoy the conveniences of a central location. Don't miss your chance to secure this potential building site in a great little town, an easy commute, near US 40 and I-70.

237 S Jefferson Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$810,320

57.88 Acres of productive tillable farm ground with approximately 415' road frontage. Has been split from larger parcel. Zoned A-1 (Ag). Please do not go on the property without an approved showing.

000 W County Road 450 South, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$472,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Brand new condo with the Oasis floor plan of 2100 sq ft of living space, 2 BR & Flex room, 2 full baths, open concept living space, 9' ceilings, screened patio, 2 car attached garage, many upgrades including, back up generator and tornado shelter. Truly maintenance free, member of HOA, lawn care, snow removal, and outside maintenance included.

307 Blue River Drive, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$217,000

Live upstairs. Operate downstairs. Invest once. Opportunities like this don't come around often-this rare mixed-use property in the heart of Knightstown combines retail and residential in one building, creating multiple income streams and long-term flexibility for an owner-user or investor. Downstairs, the property features a commercial winery production space (business not included) with a dedicated production area. Equipment may be purchased separately, allowing a buyer to continue the current use or reimagine the space for another retail, food, beverage, or creative concept. Upstairs, the furnished 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offers separate utilities, its own address, and independent water and electric-ideal for owner occupancy, short- or long-term rental, or employee housing. A second-floor storage area and attic provide valuable additional space rarely found in properties like this. The building has been thoughtfully updated to reduce future capital expenses. Recent improvements include a new asphalt-shingle roof in 2025, new siding in 2025, attic insulation in 2025, two new furnaces in 2024, a new AC system in 2024, and upgraded plumbing and drainage in 2021. Parking is a major advantage, with a rear lot where the city is working to create additional parking, plus ample public parking directly across the street at the town square, supporting both residential and commercial uses. Knightstown continues to gain momentum as a smart Central Indiana investment. Positioned along the I-70 corridor, the town offers convenient access to Indianapolis while maintaining a charming, walkable downtown. Ongoing revitalization, support for local businesses, and lower acquisition costs compared to metro markets make this an attractive opportunity for investors seeking growth, stability, and community appeal. The sky is truly the limit with this property.

18 N Jefferson Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$2,625,000

Approximately 35 Acres Of Farmland Available For Commercial Development This Exceptional 35-Acre Tract Sits Directly Behind The Loves Travel Stop And Just Off The Interstate 70 Knightstown Exit 115, Placing It At The Center Of A Rapidly Growing Commercial Corridor. Although It Is Part Of Other Tracts Owned By The Seller, Only This Specific Parcel Is Being Offered For Sale. The Property Will Need To Be Zoned For Commercial Use, And The County Planning Director Has Expressed A Willingness To Work With Buyers To Facilitate Rezoning For Large-Scale Development. This Area Is Considered A Prime Location For Commercial Opportunities, Including Retail, Service, Hospitality, And Logistics Uses. Two Easements, Recorded As Deed Restrictions On The Loves Travel Center, Provide Legal Access From State Road 109 Directly To The Property. Septic And Well Installation Will Be Required If Desired For Future Development. Seller Is Willing To Subdivide For Multiple Buyers. Located Adjacent To The New Henry County Community Health Facility. Taxes Are NOT Accurate.

00 S State Road 109, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of Highgarden Real Estate.

$1,125,000

Approximately 25 Acres Of Versatile Land - Knightstown, Indiana (I-70 Exit 115)... Approximately 25 Acres Of Open Farmland Positioned Directly Behind The Loves Travel Stop And Just Off The Interstate 70 Knightstown Exit (Exit 115). This Tract Is Part Of A Larger Group Of Properties Owned By The Seller; However, Only This Specific Lot Is Being Offered For Sale. The Land Currently Holds Agricultural Zoning But Offers Strong Potential For Commercial Conversion, Given Its Strategic Location, Existing Traffic Flow, And Proximity To Established Travel-Oriented Businesses. A Portion Of The Property Lies Near The Floodway And Partially Within A Flood Zone, Making It Well-Suited For Uses Such As Agriculture, Solar Farms, Trailer Storage, Outdoor Recreation, Camping, Or Other Low-impact, Flexible-Use Concepts. Higher-elevation areas provide additional placement options depending on desired development. Two Recorded Easements, Set As Deed Restrictions On The Loves Travel Center, Provide Dedicated Access From State Road 109, Increasing The Property's Utility And Keeping Access Costs Low. Utilities Will Require Installation Of A Septic System And Well, If Desired. Seller Willing To Subdivide For Multiple Buyers. Located Near The New Henry County Community Health Facility And Within A Rapidly Developing Commercial Corridor Along I-70. This Property Offers Rare Scale, Immediate Interstate Connectivity, And Strong Long-Term Investment Potential For Developers, Investors, And Users Seeking Affordable Land With Flexible-Use Options. Taxes Are NOT Accurate.

S State Road 109, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of Highgarden Real Estate.

$499,000

5+ Acres For Commercial Development - I-70 Westbound Exit Ramp. Prime Commercial Opportunity With Exceptional Visibility From Interstate 70 And State Road 109. This Cleared 5+ Acre Parcel Sits Directly Off The Westbound Exit Ramp, Offering Strong Exposure And Easy Access For High-Traffic Commercial Use. The Property Will Need To Be Zoned For Commercial Use And Is Ideally Suited For A Fast Food Restaurant, Gas Station, Convenience Store, Or Similar Roadside Business. Though This Lot Is Positioned Independently Off The Exit Ramp, It Is Part Of A Larger 134-Acre Tract Owned By The Seller-However, Only This Specific Lot Is Being Offered For Sale. Seller Will Subdivide For Multiple Buyers. Located Adjacent To The New Henry County Community Health Facility. Utilities Will Require Installation Of A Septic System And Well.

S State Road 109, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of Highgarden Real Estate.

$325,000

Updated investment property that checks all the boxes. Fully occupied, five unit building in historic Knightstown. Charming finishes, location, and appeal. Original hardwood floors, tall ceilings, and exposed brick walls mix with modern plumbing and electrical throughout. Unit 24 houses Historic Knightstown Inc and includes a show room, kitchenette, bathroom and storage. Unit 26 exudes character and features a lobby, three private offices and washer/dryer connection. Unit 28A (2nd FL) is features 14' ceilings and two large/open rooms. Unit 28B (2nd FL) is a fully renovated two bedroom apartment with open floor plan. Unit 32 is also fully renovated commercial unit. Each unit features an updated bathroom. Tenant pays gas & electric (individually metered). Owner pays water.

28 N Washington Street, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$70,000

NEW 2.02 ACRES LAND IN VERY DESIREABLE LOCATION TO THE MARKET in Knightstown! ONE OF THE BEST LOT IN THE CITY! Undeniably one of the most impressive LAND on the market today in this price point. Convenient location just on W county Rd 350 S and the I-70 exit. Great school district. Design and build your dream home on this lot. Downtown Indy 30min, Indianapolis Airport approx. 50min, Dayton Airport approx. 60 min. Love's Travel Shop just 10 min away.

0000 W County Road 350 S, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of TJ Realty Inc..

$770,000

Seven commercial acres! Approximately 1,400 feet of road frontage! Henry Community Health construction underway! Be on the front end of development taking place at this exit just east of Indianapolis! Ideal for HOSPITALITY, RESTAURANT, MEDICAL services/business plaza! So many possibilities! FULL visibility on interstate, adjacent to both Interstate 70 and new medical complex! Electricity, gas, and fiber optics all available on site. Ideal for any commercial buyer, but especially for commercial developer, may be subdivided. (There currently is a 3,600 square foot mini-storage building, with 29 rental units and an office, in fair condition, on the property. Currently, pasture grass is baled for hay.)

9020 W 650 S, Knightstown

Listing courtesy of The Michele Group.