Crothersville IN Homes For Sale

Crothersville IN Homes For Sale

View all the homes for sale in Crothersville IN at a median price for all buyers. See pricing and listing details of Crothersville real estate for sale.

Crothersville IN Homes For Sale

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Investor special with potential! Here is your chance to restore this 2 bed 1 bath to its former beauty or modernize it as you wish. Inside large rooms and original door frames add character that could be enhanced through renovation. Outside you'll find a covered front porch great for relaxing and a shady lot to make your own. Sold As-Is. Cash only.

511 Seymour Road, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Professionals.

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Affordable living in the heart of Crothersville! This 3-bedroom, 1-bath home is conveniently located in a great neighborhood just minutes from the school and all the conveniences of in-town living. The home features central air, a gas furnace, and a gas water heater for year-round comfort. Outside, you'll find a covered back porch overlooking a good-sized, fenced backyard-perfect for relaxing, pets, or outdoor activities. An attached one-car garage adds extra convenience and storage. This property is being sold as is, making it a great opportunity for first-time homebuyers, investors, or anyone looking to add their own personal touches. Don't miss your chance to own an affordable home in a desirable location!

405 N Preston Street, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Kovener & Associates Real Esta.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Fantastic 3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom Brick home conveniently located on Hwy 31 between Seymour and Crothersville and right off of an I65 exit. The real value here is the land. 1.42 acres of prime real estate in the corner of Hwy 31 and Hwy 250 right off of an I65 exit making this a very attractive development opportunity. This would be a prime retail development area and could be bought with an additional 2.36 acres next door.

2580 S US Highway 31, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate.

2.36 Acres of Prime Real Estate in the corner of Hwy 31 and Hwy 250 just off of I65 exit 41. This land would make an ideal development location for a retail development. Conveniently located off of a very busy highway and an Interstate exit. Quick drive to Crothersville and Seymour. This property could be bought with the parcel next door for a larger development opportunity.

2000 S Us Highway 31, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate.

MOTIVATED SELLERS- MAKE AN OFFER! Endless possibilities await with this beautifully renovated church in Crothersville, formerly known as Immanuel United Church of Christ. This beautiful building holds SO much history, dating back to 1874. Featuring 4,320 sq ft of versatile space and stunning original stained-glass windows, this property offers a large main area perfect for gatherings; complete with a stage, kitchen, and two restrooms. The upper level provides additional rooms that could be transformed into living quarters, offices, or storage! Whether you're envisioning a wedding venue, event rental space, business opportunity, or continuing its use as a place of worship, this unique property is full of potential and a must see! There's 2 parcels included in this sale; the additional parcel offering you a parking area! There's no building codes in Crothersville- you could live in this beautiful property by simply adding a shower!

102 N Kattman Avenue, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Kovener & Associates Real Esta.

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Welcome to 106 N Bethany Road-where timeless charm meets modern updates! This beautifully remodeled stone ranch home offers 3 spacious bedrooms, 1 full bathroom, and a layout designed for comfortable everyday living. Step inside to a bright and inviting living room overlooking the front yard, filling the space with natural light and creating a warm place to gather with family and friends. The updated eat-in kitchen features stainless steel appliances, modern finishes, and plenty of room to enjoy meals together. Throughout the home, you'll appreciate the updated luxury vinyl plank flooring, adding both style and durability. Step outside to the new oversized concrete patio, providing the perfect setting for summer cookouts, relaxing evenings, or entertaining guests. The attached one-car garage offers added convenience, while the quiet street creates a peaceful setting you'll love coming home to. With thoughtful updates throughout, low-maintenance stone construction, and a great location in Crothersville, this home is ready for its next owner. Updated Photos coming soon!

106 N Bethany Road, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Your Home Team.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Recently remodeled 2 bedroom 1 bath brick home centrally located in Crowthersville on a corner lot. New stainless appliances

300 W Howard Street, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of KGF Realty LLC.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Looking for land, space, and a home that's already been taken care of? This 3 bedroom, 2 bath manufactured home sitting on 8 acres right along Highway 31 checks a lot of boxes. Updates in the last three years include new flooring, fresh paint, a new HVAC unit, dishwasher, and water heater plus the septic was pumped in 2026. Move in and relax, the big stuff is already done. Outside you'll find a one car detached garage and several outbuildings plenty of room for equipment, storage, or hobbies. A portion of the tillable acreage is currently rented to a local farmer, bringing in a little extra income and keeping the land productive. Conveniently located between Seymour and Scottsburg with easy highway access. If you've been waiting for acreage with practical updates and a little extra income potential, this one's worth a look! Home Warranty Included!

2846 S Us Highway 31, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Keach and Grove Real Estate.

This 5.82-acre parcel represents a high-quality agricultural investment opportunity located in the fertile plains of Jackson County, Indiana. Currently utilized as productive farm ground, the property offers institutional investors a stable, low-volatility asset with a consistent history of row-crop production. The property is characterized by its efficient rectangular configuration and excellent drainage characteristics, allowing for maximum equipment efficiency and yield optimization. While the primary value driver is current agricultural production, the site's location near the Crothersville town limits and the I-65 corridor provides a secondary layer of long-term capital appreciation. As industrial and logistics footprints expand southward from Indianapolis, parcels with this level of accessibility are increasingly viewed as strategic land-bank opportunities. For the institutional collector, this asset provides an excellent entry point or portfolio "filler" that balances immediate agricultural income with the potential for future "highest and best use" conversion.

6000 S Block Us Highway 31, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Ellsbury Group.

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Welcome to this brand-new construction home in Crothersville! Conveniently located just one block from Crothersville High School, this ranch-style home offers comfortable, low-maintenance living on a desirable corner lot. The home features 3 bedrooms, 1 full bathroom, and a thoughtfully designed layout for an open floor plan with the living room flowing seamlessly into the spacious kitchen with all new appliances. Down the hall you will find all three bedrooms and bathroom featuring a large vanity and modern finishes. A finished one-car garage and concrete driveway provide added convenience, while the new construction means peace of mind for years to come. With its prime location, functional design, and fresh finishes throughout, this home is an excellent opportunity for a first home or someone looking to downsize! Schedule your showing today and be the first to make this home yours!

403 N Jackson Street, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Your Home Team.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative