Carthage IN Homes For Sale

Carthage IN Homes For Sale

View all the homes for sale in Carthage IN at a median price for all buyers. See pricing and listing details of Carthage real estate for sale.

Carthage IN Homes For Sale

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to 10170 N 725 W, a truly special 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home situated on 2.5 beautiful wooded acres within the Charles A. Beard School District. A serene, winding driveway leads you to this peaceful setting surrounded by nature, wildlife, and frequent deer sightings. Inside, the open-concept main level features abundant natural light, beamed ceilings, numerous skylights, and a cozy step-down great room with a wood-burning fireplace. The wood stove is capable of heating the entire home, adding both warmth and charm. The main-level primary bedroom offers added convenience, while a large pantry and generous storage throughout provide plenty of space. The kitchen includes new appliances that will remain with the home, along with the washer and dryer. Upstairs, the unique loft area is perfect for movie nights and includes a new projector and surround-sound system that will also stay. Outside, enjoy the low-maintenance stone exterior, a covered front porch perfect for morning coffee, a back deck overlooking the wooded property, and an awesome fire pit area for relaxing or entertaining. With a new roof, new HVAC, and so many thoughtful features, this one-of-a-kind property is difficult to find and even harder to replace.

10170 N 725 West, Carthage

Listing courtesy of Turnkey Realty of Indiana LLC.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Looking for a Country Home? This may be the one! Offering 1254 square feet on almost half an acre and full of pure charm! Three Spacious bedrooms and a Master bedroom with double closets. Kitchen, two full bathrooms and laundry room all located for convenience. Large Dining room with hardwood floors is the center point for all your gatherings. Two Detached Garages (32x24 and 14x24) with electricity and a workshop for the handy home owner! Don't forget the covered porch, the perfect spot for sipping your morning coffee or enjoying the views.

101 S Harrison Street, Carthage

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty LLC.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Excellent investment opportunity with this home to make it yours however you wish. This amazing opportunity is sold AS-IS.

111 W Henley Street, Carthage

Listing courtesy of List With Ben, LLC.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Sitting on a full lot on N Walnut St in Carthage, this 2-bed, 1-bath single-story offers 1,218 square feet of livable space, a detached garage, and the kind of bones that reward a buyer willing to bring their vision. The math is straightforward: buy below market, build instant equity, own something worth significantly more than what you paid. Built in 1898, the home carries real character - wood construction, a full-width breezeway, and a yard with room to breathe. Central heat and air are in place. Cosmetic updates throughout will unlock the upside, and at this price point, there's meaningful room to do it right and still come out ahead. This is priced for a buyer who sees value where others see work

406 N Walnut Street, Carthage

Listing courtesy of Gardner Property Group.

Escape to Hancock County! Build your forever home on this gorgeous, character-filled wooded lot. The seller is currently staking and finalizing county approval for a mini-subdivision, making it easier than ever to bring your builder and break ground. The acreage is estimated to be 7.75+/-. Want even more room? There are a few options depending. This is the blank canvas you've been waiting for!

400 S, Carthage

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

This nearly 32-acre property offers the perfect blend of rural privacy and convenient access to downtown Greenfield. Approximately 1.5 acres are currently not being farmed, creating an ideal homesite with soil testing already completed for septic approval, saving you time and upfront costs. The majority of the acreage is productive, tillable ground currently leased to a local farmer practicing organic farming methods, providing immediate passive income potential. At under $18,000 an acre, this property presents an exceptional opportunity for investors, builders, or anyone looking to create their own private homestead while generating income from the remaining acreage. Don't miss your chance to secure versatile land in a highly desirable area.

9350 W 1100 N, Carthage

Listing courtesy of Grange Real Estate.

Calling all stylists! Turn-key opportunity to own an established salon business with everything in place to start operating right away. This well-equipped space offers a functional layout designed for salon services, making it ideal for an owner-operator or investor looking to step into a ready-to-go business. The property includes a basement for additional storage, a bathroom, and original hardwood flooring that adds character and charm to the space. Whether you're expanding your portfolio or launching your own business, this salon presents a great chance to own a move-in-ready operation with key updates already in place.

6 E Mill Street, Carthage

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Tower.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Looking for your next investment? Or maybe you're looking for your forever home but want something that make your own? Look no further!! This 4 acre property is ready for the next chapter! The property features two barns, a 2 bedroom 1 bath house, an attached garage and a couple carports. The home has an amish metal roof, newly blown in insulation(exterior walls), the option to heat with wood or propane, and so much more! Don't forget to explore the 4acres with the creek and wooded area! The property could use some TLC and is being sold AS-IS.

10074 N 400 W, Carthage

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty.

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Three bedroom, one bathroom home, ready for you to make it you own.

307 Henley Avenue, Carthage

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative