Butlerville IN Homes For Sale

Butlerville IN Homes For Sale

View all the homes for sale in Butlerville IN at a median price for all buyers. See pricing and listing details of Butlerville real estate for sale.

Butlerville IN Homes For Sale

$60,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Investors wanted! This property needs some TLC but has a potential for three bedrooms, 1 bath and extra rooms which could be a family room, brekfat nook etc. There is also a one car detached garage and an additional workshop. Bring your toolbox and make it over! Property is being sold "as is" Buyer is to do their own due diligence.

3185 N Washington Street, Butlerville

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Real Estate Experts.

$247,499
This 38 acre wooded tract on the offers an exceptional combination of wildlife habitat and recreation! Located near the Brush Creek State Fish and Wildlife Area, this tracts holds an exceptional amount of deer, turkey and other wildlife. A recent select cut timber harvest has opened up the tree canopy to allow new growth, and provide easy access to all parts of the property. Looking to add fishing to your list of summer activities? The Muscatatuck River is the northern boundary line for this property, and is well known for its Smallmouth and Largemouth Bass, Bluegill, and Catfish. Enjoy sitting on the rocky river banks and casting from the shade of towering trees into smoothly flowing water. The property is enrolled in the Classified Forest program which is designed to enhance wildlife habitat, while reducing property taxes. The property is also located nearly in the middle between Indianapolis, Louisville, and Cincinnati. Electric lines at the road. Put on your boots and schedule your showing - this one is waiting for you! Long/Lat coordinates: 39 3' 41.36, -85 30' 52.56

Tract 3: 0 N County Road 555 E, Butlerville

Listing courtesy of Landproz of Indiana, LLC.

$236,499
Welcome to the rolling hills of Jennings County, IN! This 36 acre wooded tract on the offers an exceptional combination of wildlife habitat and recreation! Located near the Brush Creek State Fish and Wildlife Area, this tracts holds an exceptional amount of deer, turkey and other wildlife. A recent select cut timber harvest has opened up the tree canopy to allow new growth, and provide easy access to all parts of the property. Looking to add fishing to your list of summer activities? The Muscatatuck River is the northern boundary line for this property, and is well known for its Smallmouth and Largemouth Bass, Bluegill, and Catfish. Enjoy sitting on the rocky river banks and casting from the shade of towering trees into smoothly flowing water. The property is enrolled in the Classified Forest program which is designed to enhance wildlife habitat, while reducing property taxes. The property is also located nearly in the middle between Indianapolis, Louisville, and Cincinnati. Electric lines at the road. Put on your boots and schedule your showing - this one is waiting for you! Long/Lat coordinates: 39 3' 41.36, -85 30' 52.56

Tract 4: 0 N County Road 555 E, Butlerville

Listing courtesy of Landproz of Indiana, LLC.

$249,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Discover the enduring charm of 5420 E North ST in BUTLERVILLE, IN. This inviting 2774 square foot single-family residence, built in 1920, stands ready for its next chapter, offering a seamless transition for its new owners. The heart of the home, the kitchen, is designed for both culinary creativity and casual gatherings, featuring an island, a peninsula, and a charming wainscot wall. Retreat to a bathroom designed for relaxation, where a soaking tub invites unwinding, complemented by the convenience of a walk-in shower. This property extends its living spaces outdoors with a welcoming patio and a porch, perfect for enjoying the fresh air. An outdoor dining area provides an ideal setting for al fresco meals, while a private pool offers a refreshing escape. Practicality is also well-addressed with a dedicated laundry room. Inquire today to experience the lifestyle offered by this exceptional residence.

5420 E North Street, Butlerville

Listing courtesy of Trueblood Real Estate.

$123,000
Discover the perfect blend of privacy and potential with this 10.45-acre wooded tract located in Butlerville. Whether you're looking to build your dream home or create a private recreational retreat, this property offers endless possibilities. A driveway is already in place, leading to a cleared area ideal for a homesite, with an additional potential building location deeper within the woods for added seclusion. Enjoy the peaceful country setting while still being just a short drive from the conveniences of North Vernon. Ideal for hunting, exploring, or building your future homestead.

E County Road 500 N, Butlerville

Listing courtesy of 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate.

$109,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
This inviting residence offers a ready-to-move-in condition, presenting an ideal opportunity for those seeking a tranquil retreat. The single well-appointed bathroom offers the convenience of design for both functionality and relaxation. With three comfortable bedrooms, this home provides ample personal space for all. A dedicated laundry room streamlines daily chores, enhancing the home's practical appeal. Outside, a welcoming yard creates an inviting atmosphere for evening gatherings. The expansive 1.25 acre lot offers considerable outdoor potential, from gardening to recreation. This property combines comfort with a generous outdoor setting, inviting you to envision your future here. All appliances to stay and immediate possession is available.

5155 E Us Highway 50, Butlerville

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Martin Miller Lamb.

$179,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Discover this brand new home. This proposed build offers a wonderful opportunity to settle into a ready-to-move-in property where everything is brand new. Envision waking each morning in one of the three spacious bedrooms, each one offering a personal space to unwind and recharge. With two full bathrooms, mornings will be a breeze as everyone prepares for the day. With 1,137 square feet of living area, this one-story home provides a comfortable and functional layout for daily living. The property sits on a generous lot, offering ample outdoor space to enjoy.

3140 N Washington Street, Butlerville

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Real Estate Experts.

$179,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Discover this brand new home. This proposed build offers a wonderful opportunity to settle into a ready-to-move-in property where everything is brand new. Envision waking each morning in one of the three spacious bedrooms, each one offering a personal space to unwind and recharge. With two full bathrooms, mornings will be a breeze as everyone prepares for the day. With 1,137 square feet of living area, this one-story home provides a comfortable and functional layout for daily living. The property sits on a generous lot, offering ample outdoor space to enjoy.

3130 N Washington Street, Butlerville

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Real Estate Experts.

$124,900
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
One Bed One Bath apartment inside a custom pole barn structure. Simple living paired with functionality right off of historic Highway 50 near Nebraska, IN.

5390 N Clay Street, Butlerville

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Martin Miller Lamb.

$6,500
This .29 acre lot in the heart of Butlerville has plenty of opportunities for use. Although High School Alley runs through this property a savvy investor could find a use for this parcel. At this price point it gives you margin to explore the possibilities!

5430 E High School Road, Butlerville

Listing courtesy of 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative